Monday, November 25, 2013

Survivor Series 2013 thoughts

It's a rare sight indeed that I post on WWE, but I think I'll be doing this a little more. I'll at least be on for Pay-Per-Views of WWE and TNA. As I mentioned in the audio below, I may be moving this blog to the MMA section in 2014, but we shall see.

Anyway, here are my thoughts on how the booking for WWE's Survivor Series went! (Note: I cobbled my thoughts together through a variety of reviews. I worked on Sunday and can't be the judge of actual match quality. That said, nothing outright surprised me quality-wise when I read the full spectrum of reviews. The matches were about as good as I expected.)



For the record, this audio features a rant against WWE's slipshot booking of the Divas' SS match, praise for Roman Reigns and Mark Henry, and a long-winded defense of fans booing when they feel like WWE has ripped them off for ticket fare when booking their cards.)

Honestly, the biggest development of the night.

Saturday, September 21, 2013

A review of the minors: NXT and OVW

As I wanted to do in the last blog, I am reviewing what I've seen in the last few weeks in the major feds' feeder promotions: NXT for WWE and Ohio Valley Wrestling in TNA.



I feel like I may have come across a little negative, but rest assured, both companies do a fine job of producing a solid wrestling product. The point I tried to make with OVW was that their quick match, quick promo, regional signing style have produced a format where TNA probably can't look at their male wrestlers and be confident that they can appeal to the national audience.

That's a failure of TNA, though. It's a failure in their ability to send in talent from the major fed to refine those in OVW. It's a failure in the TNA style of trying to cram every feud in the company into one hour, limiting OVW's ability to showcase people.

I do think their women's division is being done well, but I think that has more to do with passionate talent and a variety of gimmicks. So many OVW gimmicks are interchangeable and that doesn't make it easy to make someone stand out, which is needed in a feeder.

OVW works fine as an independent fed. It's struggling as a major fed feeder, and from what I can gather from the internet, it's an issue about which they have complained to TNA.

So if you enjoy these feds, don't take any critique to heavily. I'm not criticizing the talent in terms of being entertaining for their fed. I'm criticizing their ability to distinguish themselves from the rest in order to get pushed into TNA.

Friday, September 20, 2013

State of WWE and TNA

So interesting story: I was going to talk about the minor league feeders to the major feds, NXT and OVW, but wound up spending 20 minutes ranting about each company's current booking state.

As such, I'm splitting both talks into two separate blogs. Hope you enjoy the part on the major feds.




Thursday, September 5, 2013

Thoughts on last week's SmackDown in Vegas

SmackDown was in Las Vegas a week ago. Here were my thoughts on it as well as a comparison between WWE and TNA shows.



Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Monday, July 15, 2013

Raw, Impact and WWE Money in the Bank thoughts, July 8-14, 2013

As the new week of wrestling begins, here are my thoughts on last week's shows and the Money in the Bank PPV event.



Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Raw and Impact reviews: Week of July 1, 2013

My Raw and Impact Wrestling reviews are now taking place in audio podcast form! Hope you enjoy!



Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Thursday, July 4, 2013

June wrestling reviews and thoughts on Impact Wrestling tapings

This past Saturday was the Impact Wrestling taping in Las Vegas' Orleans Arena. I'll be reviewing these shows the same as my normal reviews. June's Raw and Impact thoughts, as well as thoughts on TNA's roster purge, are in the podcast below.



Anyway, here are my brief thoughts on the taping:

NOT MY PHOTO.
- The arena was about 90 percent full on the televised side and about 70 percent on the end. The dark side was pretty much empty, so judging by the Orleans Arena's capacity, I'd guess between 4,000-4,500 people (though how many were paid attendees is another question).

- Jeremy Borash and Christy Hemme worked WAY too hard early on to get people to cheer on command. It didn't work at all during the Tara-ODB Xplosion match, and it backfired for probably the first half of the July 4 program.

- The show turned around toward the end of the first taping, when the main event match stole the show. It also may have been because the Vegas crowd mercifully got to refuse the Gut Check competitor. Holy crap was the last Gut Check terrible.

- I actually missed the Gut Check vote because I went to the concessions. I really like the Brown Bag Special as an option. It's a $75 option for $40, although not being able to pick the shirt is kind of annoying. Still, the clearance RVD shirt was pretty nice.

- The second show taping had a much more lively crowd. They popped for each match really well and the BFG Series Tag Team challenge/Battle Royal came across really well live.

- I thought the best match of the night was the ladder match between Taryn Terrell and Gail Kim. The crowd was supremely into it. They worked out some really fun spots with the ladder and the finish was actually pretty creative.

- The biggest pops were for Sting, Rampage and AJ Styles from what I could tell.

- The ability to win backstage passes for crowd noise was a nice touch and the TNA crew was really personable. They made sure the experience made people want to come back, and that's really all you can ask.

That's all I've got. If you get a chance to see an Impact taping, it's pretty inexpensive and definitely worth the investment.

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Raw/Impact Wrestling reviews (5/27 and 5/30/13): Good, Bad and Ugly

I really enjoyed formatting my stuff in the "Good, Bad and Ugly" format, so I think I'm going to do that more now. I may split the shows into separate posts, but I will definitely be working with this format.

For those who didn't see this before, I give a diatribe about my highlight and lowlight of the show. I also do an 'Ugly' section, which describes a part of the show that was unexpected, be it in a positive or negative way. It makes more sense when you see it.

Let's start with Raw!


The Good: The Shield retains World Tag Titles on Hell No - This was a great follow-up to a really funny promo between Kane, Daniel Bryan and Bret Hart. The downside to the promo was that it was a little too loving toward Bret, but this was in Calgary so what can you do? Bryan served more time in the match than anyone and it is clear that he has become a solid fan favorite who totally deserves a big singles push after this tag team breaks up. (And it is happening. Let's not kid ourselves.) The Shield have proven capable of having good matches any time they get on the air and the fact that they're allowed to win clean really adds to their credibility. I will say that WWE isn't executing this 'Daniel Bryan is the weak link' thing very well, especially when you consider that this loss is mostly due to Kane getting distracted by Bryan doing the same outside-the-ring interference he always does, (actually, Kane might have messed Bryan up,) but this was nonetheless a good use of nearly 20 minutes. The promo beforehand got a 7.2/10 and this match itself got 3.5 stars and 8.5/10.

Good-in-Brief
Dean Ambrose retains over Kofi Kingston - Match felt short, but fun while it lasted. 7/10

Sheamus/Randy Orton d. Rhodes Scholars - A tag team that isn't really a tag team beat a tag team who broke up months ago (kind of). All went hard and new tag challengers are being bred. 6.75/10

Curtis Axel d. John Cena by DQ - This match was really awesome but gets penalized for two bad calls: Cena kicks out of Axel's finisher on its first use ever, making it look like a setup move at best; and Ryback not actually running in, taking Cena outside the ring and making the match look like an afterthought. 3 stars 7.5/10 with no penalties, but 6.5/10 when penalized.

The Bad: Tons of Funk d. 3MB - Why did this have a segment? The match was bad and short, and then we were subjected to Great Khali's incomprehensible singing for Natalya's birthday. This could have been done backstage with other people, but instead we all had to watch awkwardly as we stumbled through some terrible TV. Not much else to say. It was just bad. 1 star for the match and 2/10 for the segment.

Bad-in-Brief
Cena's opening promo - There was a lot to like, specifically the elevation in stipulation so that the ambulance match isn't carrying a show. But Cena's tone was grating and I was far more interested in the crowd asking for Bret than listening to the same copy-and-paste promo Cena usually puts out to start the show. 4/10.

Alberto Del Rio d. Big E Langston - I like the booking, and it gets credit for teasing Big E-AJ dissension, but this match was too short to be interesting. You should know there's a problem when your stupid WWE App may actually have better content than what's on the TV, and Ziggler's few seconds of app promo time was better than this match. 1.5 stars for match, 4.75/10 after credit given for booking.

Triple H summary - I am irritated still by the Axel booking in that match and I'm offended at a concussion angle when you actually have people with concussions on the injured list. I just realized these bad briefs were almost to long to count as briefs when compared to the main Bad entry. 3.5/10

The Ugly: The Divas actually get some time... and USE IT! - I was so happy to see a Divas match that I didn't hate on Monday! Yes, Natalya will be back to comedy crap by next week, but they used all four of their minutes fairly competently. The Bellas, for all their many limitations, know how to tell a story with their match and are really good as a tag team. Natalya and Kaitlyn came across as really good technical and power wrestlers, respectively, and Natalya SOLD Kaitlyn's spear in a way that it needed to be sold. No nonsense, no annoying Diva crap (besides King's perverted commentary, which I swear is Vince's attempt to marginalize women's wrestling for good), just a decent match. Yeah, I'm only giving it 2 stars, but you have to start somewhere. 5.5/10 for the segment (including a half-point for giving a crap).

Ugly-in-Brief
Jericho and Heyman - This promo felt disjointed and I was really disappointed. This should have hit on all cylinders, but I couldn't get into this and while it's still good, it's definitely not where I thought it should have been. 6/10

Summer Rae scores more pins on Fandango than the IC champion - As if Wade Barrett wasn't buried enough, Miz is named special referee by the WWE App (which is a freaking waste of an app) and with his power, he embarrasses Fandango (right after beating Barrett in under 2 minutes) by knocking him out and counting a pin for Summer Rae. (who is being wasted in this role. She needs to do the wrestling she's good at soon.) The lesson: Don't let WWE even TRY to give you the IC belt if you want to win. 2.5/10

Overall: Another decent for Raw! I'm thrilled. They seem to be getting into a groove, and hopefully they can step up past this level following the Payback card. I'm not optimistic, but I am at least hopeful again. There's stuff in place that I can get interested in, and hopefully they follow through. 5.3 + .5 for WHC, Tag and Women's division setup with some actual potential = 5.8/10

Onward to Impact Wrestling!


The Good: Sting and Joseph Park beat Team 3D - Aces and Eights were on the ball all night, at least the Dudleys were. They had two promos, each of which hit their mark. The opener for the show set up the match listed here, the main event and the PPV card, all while maintaining a mixture of anger and arrogance. The other promo was a rallying cry that led to a moment of tension between the Dudleys, but nothing that should be seen as an issue. It really felt like the team was in a tenuous position and that they were rallying because their viability hangs in the balance. As for the match, it was the class of the three. Both the World and TV champion came across as threatening and their in-ring chemistry hasn't diminished at all in the time they've been in the singles ranks. Sting still proves serviceable, especially when not in singles matches, and Joseph Park's arc that he really is Abyss was worked in brilliantly here. I loved how he got excited that his brother was there and that he really doesn't know who he really is. It's just entertaining and somewhat humorous to see. The promos got 7.5 and 7.2, respectively, and the match got 3.25 stars, or 8/10 as a segment.

Good-in-Brief
8-Man Tag match: Face team beats Heel team - I'm surprised that the faces won, given that I had James Storm and Gunner pegged to win at Slammiversary, but in any case, this had a chaotic feel to it that worked. It got across the gist of each tag team well and I can honestly say I want to see more of each team after this match. The match itself drew 2.75 stars and the segment was 7/10.

Mickie James' Celebration - I would like to take this moment to bring up that if you count all the major women's World titles in history (WWF/E, TNA, NWA, AWA, WCW), Mickie James just surpassed Fabulous Moolah for most reigns ever with her current, ninth title reign (5 WWE Women's, 1 WWE Divas, 3 TNA Knockouts). Congrats go out to Mickie on this achievement. Anyway, this teased Mickie's heel turn in a seriously gradual manner, and I'm surprised they didn't do it outright, but it teased Taryn and Gail's match while setting up the Velvet-Mickie rematch. Good stuff. 7/10

Sabin and Taryn d. Kenny King and Gail Kim - King and Sabin have an excellent feud going that is somewhat marred by the return of Suicide, but hey, he's holding his own and is interesting, even if his presence is shoehorned. Both feuds are made apparent here and I'm looking forward to each payoff. 6/10

AJ Styles d. Mr. Anderson by DQ - Good match. It set up the Angle-AJ match and was a good way to end the show. There was more of TNA's show-bookending brawl fetish on display, but still good stuff to sell the Slammiversary card. 2.75 for the match, 7.25 for the segment with small bonus for selling the card.

The Bad: Hogan-Hogan drama - It's not terrible, but it is the worst thing on the show. I still have no idea how marriage is supposed to work here and I feel like TNA is telegraphing their plans too much here. Hulk and Brooke actually can act by wrestling standards, so it's not bad to watch, but it's just so out of place in this show. That's all I've got really. 4/10

The Ugly: Samoa Joe saves Dixie, and then becomes GM, I guess - These two segments were equally bizarre. Dixie Carter comes out to say that there will be a Hall of Fame announcement at the PPV, which accomplishes nothing. The Aces & Eights come out to... I guess beat her up? And then Samoa Joe and Magnus run in. The next segment is a match between Samoa Joe and Garrett Bischoff, which has no real finish, and then Joe decides the three A&8s members will tag against him, Magnus and Jeff Hardy. Everyone sold it well and it felt badass, but I don't know what to say about either of these segments besides recounting their insertion. I guess I'll give the promo a 4.75/10 and the matchmaking segment a 5/10.

Overall: A pretty strong episode that sold the Slammiversary PPV well. I am genuinely interested in how this card turns out and I'm optimistic for the Bound For Glory build that will be coming next week. 6.4/10

Friday, May 24, 2013

TNA Impact Wrestling catch-up (5/9, 5/16 and 5/23)

Much like with Raw, I'm going to polish off three straight Impact reports in one shot to get caught up. I really don't need to for the last show, but I'm going to be balanced and do for Impact what I do for Raw.

So on that note, let's get to it!


5/9/13

The Good - Abyss returns! And lays out the Aces & Eights: I went back and forth on whether to sing the praises of Kenny King's promo skills or this return, but ultimately I had to touch on this match. Kurt Angle and Sting were having a pretty damn good 3-on-2 handicap match with Mr. Anderson and Team 3D, but Abyss' return put this over the top. He came across as a true force to be reckoned with in TNA and the Aces & Eights were definitely intimidated by the man. After weeks of TNA piling on the screwed for the faces, this was a good way to get people thinking there might be some real payoff coming. Kudos! I gave the match 2.75 stars, but the Abyss return puts this thing up to an 8/10 for the whole promo.

The Bad - Angle doesn't 'get' AJ Styles, does he?: Before he went all silent on everyone, AJ said that he planned to do what he wanted for a change and didn't want to be led around. So what's Kurt and Hulk's plan to get AJ on their side? Force him into it. I suppose it's good that I'm critiquing story points and not the story itself, but this does make this unit look idiotic. This happened in the opening promo, which got 6/10 if you were curious.

The Ugly - James Storm ruins an awesome Bad Influence-Roode & Aries match: This match is probably now more famous for the backlash Austin Aries got after showing off his Speedo-covered goods to Christy Hemme, but the match is actually really good. I'd say it was the best match on the card had it had a finish. Sadly, though, that wasn't the case because James Storm decided to get himself angry about all the recruitment into Bad Influence and other insanity of this match and lay everyone out. It was certainly random and only made sense because, well, that's what special refs do, but it doesn't negate the match. The match wound up only 2.75 stars and the segment fell to 6.25/10 for the end, but it was still a fun ride.

5/16/13

The Good - Kenny King d. Petey Williams and Chris Sabin to retain X Division Title: I am quickly becoming a huge Kenny King fan. The guy is GOLD and knows how to trash talk in and out of matches, and that's just great. I'm glad they didn't just cave and let Sabin win immediately, and I'm glad this feud looks like it will continue into the Slammiversary card. Everyone in this match had something to offer, and it came together in an entertaining manner. Good stuff, and the match garners 3.25 stars and an 8/10 segment rating.

The Bad - Does anyone know how divorce works around here?: This is a weird complaint to have, but it's a real issue: How exactly does Bully Ray have the ability to just kill a divorce. Was that in the prenup? Who drafted a stipulation that stupid? I'm not sure TNA properly gets what a divorce is, and they should probably ask Kurt Angle about such things. It was brief and doesn't really enter the ratings, but as soon as this starts to pay off, I'm jumping on it.

The Ugly - Joseph Park wins a title shot by beating up D-Lo Brown: From a technical perspective, this segment was boring much of the time. D-Lo and Park's styles don't lend themselves to greatness, and there was a degree of underwhelming spirit in there. But then you realize the booking here is awesome. Park gets himself hyped like Abyss and it's clear to everyone but him that he's actually Abyss. I love it! And it's great to see a weak link in the Aces & Eights. It was a necessary move. The match was only 1.75 stars, but thanks to bonuses, the segment as a whole got up to 5/10.

5/23/13
The Good - Mr. Anderson d. Kurt Angle and AJ stares Kurt down: There were a few candidates for this category, but this match took the cake. Angle and Anderson know how to make a match work well and this was just a pleasure to watch. Angle sold his shoulder perfectly and Anderson dictated the pace in a more than satisfactory manner. AJ Styles' arrival ringside was a nice addition and added to the drama, and I LOVED that he didn't get involved, allowing this match to have a reasonably clean finish. The match itself was about 3.5 stars, but the additional storytelling gets this up to a 9/10 for the segment.

The Bad - Sam Shaw gets no time to get noticed: This seemed like such a waste. I know that his opponent had a medical issue, but giving Shaw no video package or promo time made him less important when he got beaten down. In all likelihood, he'll have to go to the Gut Check finals now, but they still need to give him some push so we're invested. More could have been done besides an Aces & Eights beatdown to postpone dealing with the issue for a week. The whole thing was a 4/10.

The Ugly - James Storm picks a partner... and everyone's invited!: This thing got weird... but in a way that I was finding myself very interested in what was happening. Having every tag team in the 4-way was necessary and was probably guaranteed, but having Shark Boy return and Robbie E used at all were good calls to add to the insanity. I like Shark Boy and his 'Shell Yeah' gimmick and while I dislike Robbie E, he didn't irritate me as much during this promo because it was clear I wasn't supposed to take his madness seriously. The weakest point was Gunner's reveal as Storm's partner. Most people forgot who he was (I did until they said his name) and he went for a silent gimmick, which didn't help matters. Overall, the segment was weird but in a good way, and it is totally worth 7.25/10.

As a whole, TNA has been really consistent in their quality. As for the show yesterday, I thought the move to  keep AJ on the fence was the right call, but I have to give them credit for waiting until just before the show was about to fade out to finally reveal that. I actually thought they were going to end for a second. Also, the Knockouts Title match was pretty solid but a possible heel turn from Mickie James and a title change made this match fairly monumental.

Here are the averages for the last few weeks:

5/9/13: 6.0/10
5/16/13: 5.9/10 + .25 for setting up this Abyss thing for an epic payoff = 6.15
5/23/13: 6.2

The quality has been rising each week, and that's a good sign. Now that the show will be at 6 p.m. and I have that time at night off, I look forward to getting this report out the same night!

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Sunday, May 12, 2013

WWE Raw review catch-up (5/6, 5/13 and 5/20/13)

Those who read my General Blog (specifically the comic reviews) know that I've been working on a crossover for Fanfiction.net that has taken up a lot of my time. That said, I haven't forgotten about my reviews here.

Simply put, I haven't been looking forward to writing these. Raw has been a generally unpleasant experience the last few weeks. It's weird, some parts of the show are done well and carry it, but so much of it angers me. As such, my system may be keeping Raw at a higher level than it should be in the competition with Impact Wrestling.

I am still judging by segments, but to save space on these three reviews (yes, I'm just going up to this week in order to be completely caught up), I'm FINALLY utilizing by "Good, Bad and Ugly" system to recap. The Good and Bad are self-explanatory, but the Ugly is something unexpected (either positive or negative) that evoked a reaction of sheer amazement from me. Let's get to it!


5/6/13

The Good - Randy Orton d. Damien Sandow (3.25 stars): A surprisingly fun match given I had no expectations at all for it. Damien did a song parody of Randy's music and then managed to get some actual offense in. I never expected Sandow to win, but the fact that he looked competent against a legit main eventer means A LOT, and WWE should make a point of doing this with every match (wishful thinking, I know). Good segment all around, and for those curious, this got an 8.25/10 when I rated it.

The Bad - Heyman and Lesnar trash Triple H's office: Holy crap, did this thing just not want to die. This freaking segment went on for over TWENTY MINUTES and most of it was Heyman just standing around with a camera making snide comments about the building and random people. I literally caught myself thinking, "Did I just watch two guys ride up an elevator for 45 seconds?" And yes, I did watch that. And are we supposed to believe that WWE is THAT easy to enter? If that's the case, then the New Age Outlaws should have just busted in when they did that 'TNA invading WWE' schtick a few years back. Lastly, I love how Triple H just shrugs all this crap off and says, 'I've got two offices, b**ch!' It's just a lovely way of letting everyone know that this segment didn't accomplish a damn thing. Ugh. By the way, this got 2/10.

The Ugly - Kaitlyn's secret admirer: I don't know how to feel about this. I'm thrilled that the WWE writers have gotten their heads out of their ass long enough to actually write a storyline for some Divas, but I really am depressed if THIS is their best work. Kaitlyn has a secret admirer who is texting her from a hidden number (technology that NO ONE has, by the way) and Khali is volunteered by Natalya to act as a spy. What? There's nothing technically wrong with it, but it just feels surreal and I can't believe this is getting green-lighted. Then again, this is the company that sees a problem when the models they hired to wrestle leave after years of no crowd reaction to pursue actual modeling... then solve that problem by hiring more models instead of raiding SHIMMER or Chikara's rosters. I think I should just write a master's thesis on all the things wrong with WWE's promotion of women's wrestling, but this blog will be long enough as is.

5/13/13

The Good - Mark Henry and Sheamus sell the Texas Bullrope Strap Match: I will say right now that I HATE strap/bullrope matches. They are the same formula every time: One guy beats up the other most of the match, when he's ready to touch each corner, the other guy sneaks behind and does the same, then they fight for who touches the last corner. It's stupid. BUT, I will say that Henry's feats of strength and the mic skills he and Sheamus showed on this show were great. I'm fairly sure I'm missing the point of what WWE wants, because Sheamus looks like the heel, but it's still fun. (Seriously, though, all the promos have been Henry performing awesome feats of strength and Sheamus kicking him in the face. No new viewer is going to understand why people boo Mark Henry.) I may be odd, but I love the interactions between these characters. Promo got 7/10, by the way. (The Elimination Tag match got a 9/10, but I wanted to talk more about this promo. I try to keep to the highlight of the show normally, but it's HARD to sell a bullrope match to me, so I felt it deserved credit.)

The Bad - Kofi Kingston d. Damien Sandow in under 3 minutes: You know how earlier in this blog I wrote I could write a master's thesis on the problems with the Divas division? Well, I guess I'll make a doctoral thesis out of WWE's secondary title picture. Seriously, after all the good you did for Sandow against Orton, you have him take an ass-beating to Kofi freaking Kingston? I like Kofi, but he's been booked as a joke champion. Hell, ALL the U.S. and Intercontinental champions in the past year have been booked as joke champions. Does WWE actually think winning in under three minutes helps anyone? It doesn't. The winner can't showcase their full move set or get the crowd to rally behind them, and the loser looks like a total b**ch for being unable to last long enough for the bathroom lines to clear up. WHY does WWE even bother trying to put so many people on Raw? YOU HAVE SIX HOURS OF TV CONTENT! You have more than enough time to give everyone at least 8 minutes of wrestling. Heck, longer matches mean your writing team doesn't have to do as much work writing feuds and backstage crap, which is great considering their track record recently. This segment is everything wrong with WWE today, and it gets 1.5/10.

The Ugly - The Y2J-Fandango Dance Off: This segment suffers from what I call 'Going Too Long syndrome.' Nothing was that bad, and I like that they actually flew out Jericho's dance partner from Dancing With The Stars, but Fandango's over-sexualized voice makes this back-and-forth unbearable. I hear 'sex sells' so often, but I think Linkara says it best, "Sex doesn't sell. Porn sells." If women in skimpy outfits and guys talking dirty (leaving sex to your imagination) sold, Wonder Woman would not only have a TV show by now, it would be the highest rated thing in television history regardless of its quality. But she doesn't, and this is stupid. Hell, the reason Edge and Lita's 'live sex celebration' in 2005 was so high-rated was because WWE convinced enough idiots that they were actually going to show free porn on cable television. Where was I? I got off track. But yeah, the only other thing good to come out of this was Summer Rae actually got a chance to showcase a dimension to her character besides 'dancing bimbo,' but this was a mess, and I gave it 4/10

5/20/13

The Good - The Shield d. Hell No and Kofi (4 out of 5 stars) - This was a TV Match of the Year candidate easily. I was pumped by the end of this one. Team Hell No and Kofi actually had me thinking that they could get the win for a period of time here, but The Shield continues to be booked solidly by getting a win. Completely clean too. I loved this. Whoever has been in charge of the Shield storyline needs to be head writer because he gets how to make people give a crap about people in matches. The Shield looks impressive every time, and with the exception of 3MB (whose existence continues to baffle me), everyone comes out looking fairly strong for hanging with them. Good stuff, and this of course gets a rare 10/10 from me.

The Ugly - Paul Heyman brings in Curt Axel, and Triple H gives no f**ks - I need to go out of order on this one. I was really into this promo at the beginning. Heyman said he was going to bring in the newest Next Big Thing for this company, and I was excited to see a guy get pushed. He went with the man formerly known as Michael McGillicutty. While I'll admit, this guy was good in the ring on NXT, he was boring as piss on the microphone and honestly, having Heyman as his manager early on could make him look like a threat. I liked this idea and Heyman sold him PERFECTLY.... And then the other shoe dropped. Triple H let the air out of this guy's hype in one "the grown-ups are talking" line and one slap to Axel's face. This move baffled me completely. In what world does making this kid look like a total punk help him become credible in any way? This segment got a 6/10 from me, and I left with some hope that Axel would pull a Shelton Benjamin and steal a win over The Game...

The Bad - Triple H has a concussion... I think?... : Ok, so let me get this straight... Triple H comes out and embarrasses Curt Axel on national TV earlier in the show. They have a match where Triple H is clearly getting the better of him and about to win. (He even hits the spinebuster, which is of course the setup to his finisher, The Pedigree.) But then, with one move left in the tank, he leaves the ring and rolls around with a 'concussion' in what felt like one of the most awkward and possibly ill-timed angles ever produced by the company? I'm starting to think the @CrankyVince and @HugeWolfDick users are actually Vince McMahon and Triple H, and all those crazy things they say are actual thoughts. Because someone out of their mind is clearly running the Triple H angles to think that this episode was going to make Curt Axel interesting. This got 2/10 from me and that's being generous.

Show averages: Taking all the promos and matches into account, here are my averages for each show:

5/6/13: 5.0/10
5/13/13: 5.1/10 + .25 for a strong, 24-minute match = 5.35
5/20/13: 5.7/10 + .25 for a 20-plus minute match + .25 for actual commitment to the Divas = 6.2/10

As a final aside, I do want to applaud AJ Lee on being by far the most interesting Diva today and for finally showing off in the ring. That said, it should speak volumes about this division's credibility when knowing ONE submission hold makes you an unstoppable force. But hey, from the independent matches I found, AJ is actually a really competent wrestler, so maybe they'll give her time to showcase that skill! (I'm an optimistic bastard today, aren't I?)

With my off days falling on Tuesdays now, I should be able to do Raw reviews much easier now, so there's that to look forward to. See you soon!

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs. Also, like Wrestling Memes' page at www.facebook.com/wrestlingmemes. The dude produces some funny stuff. Credit to the fine people at the page for the images in this blog.

Thursday, May 9, 2013

TNA Impact Wrestling review (5/2/13)

TNA will be moving an hour later at the end of the month due to no one watching the first hour because it's too early hearing the fans' desires to have the show be an hour later. I firmly look forward to the day that I no longer need to use DVR to watch the show's first hour. For now, though, let's go over last week's Impact.


Hogan and Sting make amends, Matt Morgan and Sting for a title shot? - I'll admit that the first half of this promo was excellent. I got the feeling of renewed solidarity that I was hoping to feel and it's a testament to Hogan and Sting at how they can keep a crowd hooked like this, even when it's just them giving petty bickering. Then Morgan came out and did his stream of awesome rage, and I'm really getting into this show. Where this promo goes wrong is when Hogan decides that STING should face Morgan for the title shot. Why? What has he done to earn it? Granted, creating a No. 1 contender is pretty much the only thing this show hasn't done while setting up for Slammiversary, butthis is a good time for a red herring face savior, like an Angle, Joe or Sabin. Morgan would be an interesting payoff, but Sting? It makes some sense, but I've seen it before and know it can't end well. This does drag a possible-8 promo down to a 7/10.

Chris Sabin's rehab video - This wasn't a bad video, but it was still lacking compared to actual content. And it, again, made me wonder why you wouldn't push this guy hard in a World Title feud instead of an X title feud. 5/10

Sabin beats Zema Ion and Sonjay Dutt - This match was short, but I assume Sabin isn't in long, high-flying match condition yet, so it's fine to return him into the ring. I stand by my statement that I don't care about Zema Ion. Maybe it's the hair. Match was 2.25 stars and segment was 5.5/10.

Rob Terry squashes three jobbers, Bully Ray gives D-Lo Brown a shot at Kurt Angle - I'm really glad Aces & Eights was around to have a longer segment than the Rob Terry match, because now there's something good in this segment. Rob Terry's match was novel, but it only served to make me realize that three roster spots better spent on a tag team or a couple of Knockouts are being squandered on these guys. The match was 1.25 stars, but the Bully Ray promo drags the segment up to a 4.8/10.

Three tag teams seeking a belt? I'm good with that! - It seems surreal to me that TNA can be operating on four tag teams (if you count the Aces & Eights stable as a fourth team) and still have it be the most compelling part of the show. Austin Aries and Robert Roode showed a nice bit of solidarity, Bad Influence continued to get under Aries and Roode's skins, and Chavo Guerrero and Hernandez wound up standing tall with James Storm. It was a similar formula to last week, but it still worked nonetheless. 7.2/10

Tara and Gail Kim talk, Sabin says things and Angle stares at D-Lo - This whole segment screamed 'set everything up.' It went WAY longer than needed. 3.5/10

Angle beats D-Lo in an I Quit match - Was there a reason this is happening on free TV? The stipulation, not the match with D-Lo Brown. Honestly, this was better than I expected, though I am amazed that more interference wasn't done. I give the match 2.5 stars and 6.25/10 for the segment.

Angle calls out AJ Styles - I like Angle's intensity here, but why is it that everyone on Team TNA is trying to bully AJ into joining their side. You guys are making a terrible case here. And this thing is dragging to next week. Lovely. The promo was inoffensive, but it loses a half point for doing the same damn thing all over again. 5.5/10

Taryn Terrell and Mickie James d. Tara and Gail Kim, Gail on Taryn BEATDOWN - I think the Knockouts have really stepped up by having an intense feud take up time while Velvet is injured. This has been the best match of the night, and would be even higher if this company would stop ending all their women's matches with frickin' roll-up pins! The post-match brawl should add to the psychology of what's been happening, especially seeing as Gail Kim just WRECKED Taryn's leg with a ring-post figure four. The match is 2.75 stars and the segment as a whole gets bonus points to reach 7.5/10.

Sting beats Matt Morgan to become No. 1 contender - This match wasn't terrible, but it certainly wasn't the best thing either man has produced. Sting really shouldn't be trying to go with larger opponents anymore. That requires speed to look good and while his technique is fine, he needs a younger man's speed repetoire to do what he wants to do. As for the match booking, like I said, I honestly believe this is one of the few situations where it's better to make a new No. 1 contender and build for a month than go with the option that currently makes the most sense. Yes, Sting probably works from a storyline perspective, but unless you plan on playing people's fears that you'll actually put the belt on a 50-plus-year-old man, your main event to one of your only four PPVs is kind of a giveaway. I pretty much expected Bully Ray to win anyway, but I really don't buy Sting winning. Then again, this IS TNA, so maybe they're banking on that fear to make everyone feel concerned. As for the match, it was a 2-star affair, and the segment loses ground to fall to 4.5/10.

Overall: I really do enjoy Sting as a competitor, which is why the booking decision only dragged a little. But come on! The Aces & Eights are being build up well. Why does it feel like the only people being built competently on the face side are past their prime. I will note that if RVD signed with TNA, I'd be shocked because this would be the week to use him. Anyway, this was one of TNA's worse weeks and the score showed it. 5.7/10

Monday, May 6, 2013

WWE Raw review (4/29/13)

The first month of this competition is now over, and here's the Raw review for last week's show.


Ricardo Rodriguez d. Zeb Colter and Big E. Langston - This was a battle of sidekicks to determine the stipulation for the World Heavyweight Championship match, and aside from the fact that Big E. - the only one who should really be booked as a threat physically - lost the freaking match, this wasn't a bad bit of humor and made sense in WWE's style of programming. The match would have pulled two stars if it went with a logical ending, but it will settle for 1.75 stars and 5/10 for the segment.

Cena and the Make-a-wish kids - This wasn't exciting, but I do appreciate what John Cena does here and it's one of the few times I don't mind WWE pushing itself as a community company. 4.5/10

Seriously, who approved this creepy thing?
Randy Orton d. Cody Rhodes - Holy crap! This was awesome! Cody and Randy work really well together and it's great to see that they got some time to work here. Cody came off looking more competent than he has at any point in the last few weeks and the Beautiful Disaster is still an epic move that should be allowed to finish more people. A lot of people weren't happy about the second RKO, but I really didn't mind given that it makes sense a heel would try to blindside a face. I give the match 3.5 stars and 8.25/10.

Naomi d. Nikki Bella via ref taking complaints seriously? - I want to give the WWE points for actually having two real feuds in the Divas division that make some sense. I really do. But it's hard to do that when matches only last a minute, and decisions are overturned randomly. The commentators were joking about instant replay, but given the commentary last week, I honestly am concerned the writers are doing an angle where Twin Magic doesn't work because one girl is 'natural' and one isn't. I suppose I'll settle on 6/10 for the segment.
Anyone really think WWE isn't shameless enough to do an
angle based on this?
Shield is awesome and 3MB... exists - I have no earthly idea why 3MB continues to be put on television if this is what they're being used for. Yes, I heard Heath Slater had a good match on Main Event, but the huge portion of the WWE audience only watches Raw on a consistent basis. If this is how they're being portrayed on the 'A' show, it doesn't matter what they do when fewer than 1 million people are watching. 

I don't understand how a company can end their brand extension because they don't think enough people watch the secondary show to give it credibility, and yet they want to focus on building credibility of their 'A' show jobbers by giving them time on the 'B' shows they know nobody watches. Stephanie McMahon cannot possibly believe that by having one continuity and building all the feuds on Raw, that will somehow make people want to seek out SmackDown and Main Event to 'get the whole story.' How often does that tie-in theory work in comics? How many people actually stick with the books tied into an event comic? Not that freaking often! They buy to complete the story, the book gets a quick spike, and then readers leave in droves. You want SmackDown and Main Event to rely on one or two big ratings 'pops' per year to keep the networks around, fine. I've already limited myself to Raw as it is, so by all means, keep giving me reasons not to DVR your other programming.

Oh, this was a Shield segment, right? Yeah, all three of them gave nice, emotionally charged promos and the Hell No run-in helped increase the investment in the big tag title feud that appears imminent. I guess I'll go 7.5/10 for the segment.

Dolph Ziggler d. Kofi Kingston in Neverending Feud Story Part 1,942: Championship Edition - You've seen one of these matches, you've seen them all. The only difference is there were title belts around their waists. WWE seems to have locked in on the formula to diminish the interest in Champion vs. Champion matches, matches between two solid workers, and secondary champions all in one segment. Nothing bad here and the match was its usual 2.5-star self, but it is a sad day when I find I no longer care about these two competing against each other. 5.5/10

Building the Divas Title feud/Ryback whining about some shizz - Oh look, more actual Diva content! I love that this exists, even though I'm certain this will not lead to more in-ring airtime. I'll give two bonus points and go 7/10 for the sheer joy I feel toward the work that seems to be going toward making the Divas credible, even if it's only to push a reality show.

Jack Swagger d. Zack Ryder - This existed. I don't care about either man anymore and Swagger now sucks interest out of a room like a vacuum. Get a better manager, Jack, and be less awkward. I no longer care for you. 1.25 stars and 3.5/10

Alberto Del Rio d. Antonio Cesaro - Next up on the 'Kill the U.S. Championship Show,' Alberto Del Rio beats the guy who challenged for the belt literally two days later. Why they didn't just job a 3MB member or someone like that is beyond me, but at least they gave Cesaro some offense this time. Actually, I shouldn't hit this one that hard. At least Cesaro seemed like he belonged in the ring with a main eventer at times in the match. The match was 2.5 stars and the segment translates to 6/10.

If this image is in a wrestling blog, you're doing
something VERY wrong.
Mark Henry Tug of War/Fandango-Khali dance off - I almost forgot about the Mark Henry bull crap, and was ready to lambast it until WWE proved its incompetence by writing a second, even crappier gimmick segment in the same damn hour. These three-hour shows are just a pain in the ass sometimes. WWE Raw should not feel like that bizarre Brady Bunch Variety Hour from the 1970s. Henry's random thing at least built up a feud and could be argued to exist, but the Fandango thing did nothing for anyone and I despise it. These segments will go 2.5/10 and 1/10, respectively.

Shield beats the WWE's top singles and tag team competitors - There is something to be said for the accomplishment given here. The Shield has officially beaten every level of competitor in this company since their debut and they are a serious threat to anyone. I'm still concerned that the writers don't have a real plan, especially considering that they will eventually have to go for singles titles and building these guys individually really hasn't been much of a priority, but for now, this works for me. Match: 2.75 stars. Segment: 7/10

Overall: This show was much improved over last week, and there's actually some things to be excited about again. Huge portions of the show were uninteresting, but at least this time there were some awesome things to mitigate that problem. The show averages out to a 5.3, but I'm going to add .5 for having some better effort in place for at least SOME of the competitors and divisions. There actually feels like there's some direction outside of Triple H and Cena's feuds and that's a big deal to me. 5.8/10

Thursday, May 2, 2013

TNA Impact Wrestling Review (4/25/13)

TNA last week was live, which is always nice, so let's talk about their little venture into Pennsylvania.


Teasing a Fourtune reunion, Bully Beatdown-Impact Edition, and the Return of 3D - There is so much win in this segment that I can't do it all justice. James Storm gives AJ Styles credit for developing another submission hold and spends the early portion of this segment appealing to AJ in the crowd and calling out Aces & Eights. Bad Influence talks about reviving Fourtune (which I find odd, given that the stable had next to no real success and came during TNA's crap period) and humor ensues. The class of the promo, though, is when Aces & Eights comes in, beats down Storm, beats down Joseph Park (who intervenes), and then Ray and Devon hit the first 3D through a table in two years. SO much awesome here.

The promo continues into the next segment and it's mostly Bully Ray calling out Hulk Hogan for later tonight. Ray on the microphone is always a good thing and this got me excited for the final segment. The two segments will get a 9/10 and a 8/10, respectively.

Hyping the title matches, specifically the Knockouts title - I get that they want to both keep people interested in the show and give everyone a breather after the long promo, but we have gotten pretty deep into the show without any action that was actually scheduled to happen. 3/10

Taryn Terrell d. Tara (aka Tiffany v. Victoria) - I just realized how small the knockouts division is. I feel like it should have around 10 women readily available, especially since Velvet is battling injuries and Madison is out for months with pregnancy. But anyway, this match was surprisingly good. Taryn has clearly been working on her game since leaving WWE, and having 6:30 with Tara to tell a story in a match only helped matters. A secondary feud for women. I LOVE IT! 2.25 stars for the match and 6/10 for the segment.

Rob Terry d. Jessie Godderz (w/ Robbie E) - There are some gimmicks I just know I'll never care about and just want to go away. Robbie E is one of them, and adding in Mr. Pectacular here isn't helping matters. The right guy went over, but this just sucked. 1.25 stars and 3.5/10.

Bad Influence influences Bobby Roode and MORE video packages - Bobby Roode is next to be recruited for the return of Fourtune and Austin Aries is NOT happy. I like the possibility of in-team tension but prefer Aries and Roode both joining to create a far more emotionally unstable Fourtune. Oh, and more talk about stuff we already saw a few weeks ago. Kudos to TNA for trying to be new-viewer-accessible, but I'm not a new viewer so this is just redundant. I guess the whole thing rounds out to a 5/10.

World Tag Team Championship match - Chavo and Hernandez retain against Roode and Aries - This match felt longer than the 9 minutes it got, but I think that's good in this case because it was due to Spike not breaking the match up with a commercial. Roode and Aries' tension after the Fourtune recruitment was done well and Bad Influence is MONEY on guest commentary. My only issue is how Bad Influence ran interference because it wasn't necessary to tell the story, but overall a fun segment. I suppose the match gets 2.75 stars and the segment is 7/10.

Matt Morgan has a SOLUTION - Morgan has been randomly on the sidelines for a while now, but this segment really played that off well. He is established to be a legitimate threat and Hogan puts over that he no doubt could be the solution. BUT Hogan wants him to be honorable about it and not be a hired hand, like Morgan wants to be. I don't see the issue as that big because Morgan fighting Bully Ray SHOULD be for the title anyway, but Hogan at least has an argument in place. I really hope TNA has a good payoff here because Morgan's storyline just got way more compelling. 7.6/10

World Women's (Knockouts) Championship - Velvet Sky retains against Mickie James - Well... that was anti-climactic. The match was really well-hyped. The crowd was INSANELY into it. Mickie and Velvet told a good in-ring story and for the most part sold her knee injury well. The match got more time than any other match on the card and kept me interested the whole way through. And then it just kind of... ended. I mean, come on, a roll-up pin again? This felt like a good time to turn Mickie James heel by going too hard on Velvet's knee. That may still be the story, but if Velvet needed to go over here, couldn't it have been a move that Taryn Terrell didn't just use to finish her match earlier? The match was pushing for 3.25 stars for a while, but it'll have to settle for 2.75 stars and a 7/10.

Hogan and Ray confront each other; Sting kills a segment - This promo was actually pretty damn impressive for a while. Both men bounced off each other and I was really getting hyped. Unfortunately, once Aces & Eights came out, things went a little screwy. The 50-something-year-old Sting comes in and LEVELS ALL OF ACES & EIGHTS WITH A BASEBALL BAT. It would be one thing if he took most of them out in the dark, but once they all saw him? Is he Mr. Miyagi? What the hell. I will admit, it was a nice moment live and the crowd really got me to mark out for a few moments, but this is kind of nonsensical thinking back. This would have gotten another 9, but I have to dock points here and give it a 7.5/10.

Overall: I really had fun with this episode. Yeah, there was a lot of disappointment in the payoff, but a lot of good setup has been done. I can only hope the crowd stayed into the taped episode this week. The whole show averaged out to a 6.4/10.

Monday, April 29, 2013

WWE Raw review (4/22/13)

Let's go through the Monday Night Raw (sort of) live from England last week!


Triple H trolls Heyman; accepts challenge - Short, sweet and to the point. Heyman receives an email from the not-so-anonymous COO that the won't be at Raw; Heyman trashes him; turns out H was there all along; hijinks ensue. Good segment. 8/10

R-Truth d. Antonio Cesaro - This was a squash match where the only thing redeemable was that Truth is back to his entrance rap. Love that thing. The Shield flies in on a chopper just before commercial, which was cool. But yeah. This happened. 5/10

Damien Sandow d. Brodus Clay - Incredibly, the tag division has a secondary feud. How about that?! The match was incredibly short and not that interesting, but the crowd was really into it. It was followed up by AJ Lee getting set up for a possible run at the Divas title. At least there's some development happening. 1.75 stars for the match; 4.5/10 for the segment.

Shield give a promo - I liked this promo. It was really intense and hyped why a match with the Undertaker is so huge for the Shield here. Good stuff. 6.5/10

Dolph Ziggler d. Chris Jericho - These two are just really knowledgeable of each other in the ring and it shows here. Their match was a good technical watch, although its ending cost it. I get what they were doing with the Fandango theme playing, but man, that killed the buzz for me. The match was 2.75 stars, and the segment was 6.75/10

Tensai d. Cody Rhodes - A decent, short match, but it was the same basic match as the Sandow match. The difference was the crowd was less strong here. The segment was helped far more by the Daniel Bryan and Kane comedy. DIAGRAMS! 1.5 for the match/5.5 for the segment.

Ryback promo - Video packages. Video packages everywhere. And a decent but brief interview. 3/10

Langston squashes Ryder - Geez, this show is dragging! 3/10

The Shield d. Undertaker & Hell No - THIS is why I watch these shows! The crowd was firmly behind the match and everyone was hitting on all cylinders. The right team went over and yet everyone looked strong throughout the process. I gave this match a 3.5-star rating, and the segment translates to an 8.25/10

Foley and Cena have a chat - There's nothing wrong with this, but it's these annoyingly short segments that make this blog a chore. 5/10

Fandango squashes William Regal - A waste of Regal. The Jericho brawl afterward was ok, but this didn't do much for me. 3.75/10

AJ wins No. 1 contender Battle Royal - I KNOW AJ is more useful in the ring than this. The strategy of feigning unconsciousness is creative, but it just made the match feel... stupid. We have a good feud now, but it was set up in a dumb manner and somehow managed to overlook Nikki Bella, who seems to actually have a small in-story beef with Kaitlyn. How sad is it that the storylines here are so pathetically small that ANYTHING feels like a storyline? 1.5 stars for the match and 4.25/10 for the segment.

Foley confronts Ryback and Cena gets revenge (sort of) - Foley's talk was decent, but I have no idea why it existed. The commentary team acted so blindly face that they ignored the damn story (asking Ryback how it feels to be left alone with the Shield when that's the WHOLE BASIS OF THE FEUD). And SuperCena clears house. Lovely. 5.5/10

Overall: I have really not been a Raw fan lately. There are a lot of small things I like, but they're bogged down by A LOT of crap. Raw's writing crew needs to work to make this show feel like most of it isn't a waste of time. 5.3/10


Thursday, April 25, 2013

Impact Wrestling Review (4/18/13)

With Raw now taken care of, here are my thoughts on last week's TNA Impact Wrestling!



Kurt Angle v. Garrett Bischoff/Wes Briscoe (win via pinfall) - A surprisingly good match that had a logical conclusion and set up the theme of 'Aces & Eights beats people up' for the night. Bischoff and Briscoe actually looked competent in there and that's really all you can ask for with these new guys. I'd say the match is 2.5 stars and the segment gets 6.5/10.

X Division Title Match: Kenny King (c) retains over Petey Williams and Zema Ion - The division that was once about No Limits is now about 230-pound weight limits and only wrestling three-way matches, and while that is an oddly specific division, I liked this match. Kenny King is an awesome competitor and I love me some Canadian Destroyers. My only complaints are that I still don't give a crap about Zema Ion and that this division appears to be moving in the direction of 'just line up challengers and have them wrestle the champ because they won a match. That said, this was a fun watch. 2.75 stars for the match and 7/10 for the segment.

Brooke Hogan force feeds us a website and Devon does NOT wrestle for his title! - Brooke Hogan and Christy Hemme engage in the worst product placement ever just as Devon is supposed to defend his TV title against Magnus. This leads to Magnus getting beaten down. Incredibly, that's a logical move on Aces & Eights' part. I like it. But the stupidity of the website thing hurts it. I'll go 6/10.

Knockouts No. 1 contender's bout: Mickie James defeats Miss Tessmacher - I gave this match 1.75 stars, but it REALLY should have gone higher. What killed it was the momentum of the match constantly being killed by ODB trying to referee the match. Refs should NOT take up this much attention. If you must do this angle, use a rookie from the indies who can build to this in a few months, not competitors who distract the viewer. Points for giving women time to go, though. 5/10 for the segment.

Joseph Park takes a beating and tag title intrigue? - I love when the tag titles are given prominence. Roode and Aries, as well as Bad Influence, bounce off each other in an entertaining manner until the face champions come in and kick some ass. THAT is how you do it. Sadly, this section loses points for Joseph Park trying to add real-world logic to a wrestling show. I don't mind his character, but trying to annul the marriage through the courts? Come on, now! I hate when shows acknowledge they're in the real world because it makes me wonder what the hell is written on their contracts to begin with that insane sh** like this can happen. Where was I? Oh yeah, 6.2/10 to average out the 8/10 and 4.4/10 the two sections got.

TV Title match (for real): Devon (c) pins Samoa Joe - This was a decent match for the time it had, but it was so short and the beatdown came so quickly that I wound up feeling disappointed. This should have been better than what it was given how much it was hyped during the show. 2 stars and 5/10.

Main Event: AJ Styles (win by submission) v. James Storm - AJ Styles not wanting to put any effort out at the start was a nice call to his newfound (lack of) spirit, and his more grounded style was ideal for his mood. I think adding a new submission hold is also a nice piece of storytelling for AJ. The best thing, though, is that he still doesn't commit one way or the other, but he makes himself look enough like a heel that Aces & Eights is satisfied. Everything about this was executed well and I'm looking forward to this storyline's continuation. 3 stars for the match and 8/10 for the segment.

Overall:  I think this episode was an improvement. There was some spectacular and nothing was too offensively bad. The show could be better, but it was solid for what it was. I average it out to a 6.2/10.

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Monday, April 22, 2013

WWE Raw Review (4/15/13)

It's taken a week to give myself enough time off my sickbed to write this, but here we are!

Before the next Raw hits tonight, I have to give my thoughts on last week's. So let's get to it.


Handicap Match: Big Show v. Randy Orton/Sheamus - I'll keep my thoughts brief this week to save time. This was actually a pretty nice match if you ignore the fact that this match had been done on SmackDown and we're supposed to be keeping one solid continuity here. It was short and inoffensive, and was probably 2.5 stars out of 5 in my view, so I give the whole thing a 6.5/10

Heyman calls out HHH, oh and 3MB was there for some reason - 3MB thought the could call out The Shield but got Brock Lesnar and Paul Heyman. Seriously, what was the point of putting these guys into a stable again if they never use their numbers advantage to win? The two parts of this segment didn't really have much connection, but were nonetheless entertaining, so it also gets a 6/10.

United States Championship: Antonio Cesaro v. Kofi Kingston - The match itself was good, but we're seriously blowing this feud off in under a week? Their only match happened on SmackDown. Am I supposed to care about the other brands or not? Cesaro's gimmick has fallen to yodeling because apparently two polarizing political issue gimmicks in one company is too damn much, and despite the fact that he had been getting reactions for a time, Vince has decided to kill the Cesaro push.

Um, why? I admit, I wish this had happened a while back, but the dude had grown on me and now I'm actually kind of pissed. Oh, and Kofi claiming he brought the title "back home?" Home to where? Ghana, West Africa? Jamaica? You've never been advertised as being from the U.S. You can't just suddenly claim to be American without an explanation!

The match itself was 3 stars, but it loses a point and a half for being full of so much stupid, so it only rounds out to 6/10.

World Championship 3-way promo - It took longer than I'd have liked, but I can finally get behind Dolph Ziggler's mic skills. He's finally gone beyond simply needing the Vickie Guerrero mouthpiece to keep him interesting. Unfortunately, he cannot carry boring people yet. We had a nice tease for a WHC rematch, but then Jack Swagger and Zeb Colter interrupt and beat up Alberto Del Rio. I'm starting to thing that Colter's beard is a Dementor that sucks the soul out of any segment he's in. Or it could just be that Swagger's so boring that Colter's beard is the only interesting thing on the screen when he's present, but I digress. I say 6.8 /10 with the segment losing ground only when the rodeo clowns come out.

Team Hell No v. Primetime Players: How is it that we have tag teams around to be squashed by the champs but none to actually feud with them? The action was OK, brief as it was, and gets 2 stars. The segment itself only gets 5/10.

Ryback brings it... VIA SATELLITE - Ryback provides the equivalent of a clip show to his promo, as he goes off for a LONG time about his history with John Cena. I'll admit, this ran way too long, but it was intense and I liked Ryback's promo work here. The crowd turned on it, but the crowd this week was just a poor follow-up to the one in Jersey. I'll rate this fairly high, giving it a 7.4/10.

Dueling SmackDown GMs and Wade Barrett v. R-Truth - I guess we're setting up a Barrett-Truth feud, but I really have to admit: It's hard to get invested in feuds that boil down to 'champion lost to Wrestler X. He must receive title shot!' The match itself barely made the rating limit and gets 1.75 stars and the segment gets further killed by the teasing of heel Teddy Long (who I guess makes singles matches) going against Booker T. This whole segment was awkward and only deserves 4/10.

Rhodes Scholars v. Santino and Khali - Don't know why this existed. Don't care. Let's move on. 3/10

Fandangoing gets the worst push ever... of all time - I've got nothing here. I don't know what the hell it was they were going for, but it was clear that WWE is regretting holding a Raw between a Jersey Raw and a UK Raw. This crowd had no idea what to do and the whole thing felt uncomfortable on TV. Let's hope they have a plan this week, but for now, this crap gets 4/10.

Ziggler v. Swagger - The match itself was ok, with Swagger winning, but I and no one in that crowd could really get into it. Swagger is in the same position for me that Ziggler was in a year and a half ago. Maybe that means his interest level will go up, but when you're basically the non-crazy, less good version of Kurt Angle, I don't like your chances. I give the match 2.5 stars and 6.5/10 overall

Henry kills Sheamus and Punk walks out - This was one of Punk's weaker promos, I have to admit. It's created intrigue, but that was really unsatisfying. What was satisfying was seeing Mark Henry lay out Sheamus because "THAT'S WHAT HE DO!" 6.5/10 for being able to see that.

Nikki Bella v. Kaitlyn feat. Two and a Half Men on commentary - I like that the Divas got some time to work here. I like that we actually got a 2-star match out of them. What I don't like is that I had to listen to some REALLY perverted commentary through the whole thing. No, Vince, Lawler's old man talk was NOT what made the Golden Era of women's wrestling good. I've seen this kind of feud before, but at least it's A feud. I guess 4.5/10.

Cena confronts Ryback - I was kind of into the showdown here, and for once the crowd actually took the sides WWE wants them to take. I can see both sides of the argument and think there is a good idea in here. The Shield giving Cena a beating while Ryback watches is a nice visual, although I HATE that they showed the three getting ready minutes before they attacked. It kills the whole vibe. Overall, though, I'll give it 7/10.

Total: This was not a great show. Nothing really stuck out as must-see, but there was at least some good in it, as well as a lot of indicators that WWE has to work through A LOT of booking problems. We'll see if they can in the coming weeks, but until then, they get a 5.6/10 for this show.

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Impact Wrestling review (4/11)

I'll admit, Raw's crowd on Monday put on the performance of a lifetime and no matter what the Corpus Christi, Texas crowd pulled, it wouldn't equal the rabid nature of that unit.

I guess that means TNA will have to earn my interest through compelling TV. Let's look!


TNA World Tag Team Championships: Austin Aries and Bobby Roode (c) v. Hernandez and Chavo Guerrero Jr. - This was supposedly a 2-out-of-3 falls match, but the first two falls finished so quickly we effectively got a 12-minute one-fall match with 3 minutes of sudden finishers preceding it. However, the action was strong, the match was clean, time was given and it was fun to watch. I also like that TNA didn't just open the show with talking for once. I give the match 3.25 out of 5 stars and give the whole segment an 8.2/10

Joseph Park gets legal and Devon doesn't like it. TESTIFY! - I love Park's passion in this speech, but it felt really cliche until he started talking about vigilante lawyer work (which makes no sense at all). Devon tears up the document of annulment (and I guess that's the only copy because Park's really down about that) and then beats him up. So... kudos for getting Park more active in this feud, but this was kind of weird. I think a 5/10 works here.

Teryn Terrell and Gail Kim blow off their feud (in three minutes or less!) - The feud was built well, people were behind these two wrestling (since the former Tiffany isn't too bad in the ring and Gail Kim is, well, Gail Kim), so why didn't this get more time? It was awesome in its brief existence, and Teryn didn't do badly in the post-match interview. I just feel a lot of payoff was wasted and have to give this segment 4.5/10.

Styles video package and Gut Check elimination - The video was fine for what it was. It just caught people up on the last few weeks. The Gut Check drew a lot of hate for eliminating 5-time NWA champion Adam Pearce first, which is definitely a bad call. But still, Pearce is fairly old to be starting out in TNA (in a storyline sense) and I really don't care all that much. The Gut Check segments aren't that interesting anyway and I give the whole thing 4/10

AJ Styles is confronted about his decision on whose side he's on - This was surprising, but in a good way. Styles has been told to join Aces & Eights as well as Team Hogan, and Hulk wants an answer. James Storm comes out to demand for Hulk as well, and then Bad Influence of all people come out. Daniels and Kaz apologize (to AJ and, I assume, everyone forced to watch) for the Claire Lynch crap and make a case for him to join them in an "us against the world" crusade. Honestly, they're the only ones who have made a decent case so far, so this was fun, and the part where Daniels puts over all the group's World title reigns (which only AJ contributes to) is some nice, subtle humor. It set up a Storm/Styles match and was entertaining, so how about a nice 7.5/10

Kurt Angle says things and Joey Ryan gets squashed - This was probably the trash segment of the night. It accomplished very little and forced me to watch Joey Ryan again, who got his ass handed to him by Rob Terry. This was not interesting at all. 3/10

Gut Check claims another loser/Hogan drama/Bully Ray says awesome things - Magno gets unanimously dumped from the Gut Check for competing in a terrible match a week ago. Yay. This was boring and got too much time. Thankfully, it was book-ended by Matt Morgan being a douchebag to Hogan and Bully Ray rallying the Aces & Eights, saying he must fight alone. So two really awesome things surround a boring thing. Let's say 6/10.

World Championship Full Metal Mayhem match: Bully Ray (c) v. Jeff Hardy - Hell. Yes. This was just what this show needed to end on. A feud-ending style of match between two guys used to tables, ladders and chairs (and steel chains), and a fairly clean victory. Yeah, there were complaints about Taz hinting to Ray about using the hammer, but hammers are metal and this was Full Metal Mayhem, so I'm fairly sure that's fine. My one complaint is that it was clear toward the end that Ray being set up on the table was done poorly (there is no logical sense WHY he's rolling onto a collapsible table), but otherwise, it was a fun match. I'd say 3.5 stars and 8.5/10.

Overall, the show averages out to a 5.8/10, but I'm adding .5 points for delivering on two strong World Championship matches on free television. So it actually comes out to a 6.3/10.

It was an average show that felt bigger because of the implications going on with the titles. Definitely two matches and a couple promos to check out, though I think the whole Gut Check thing has run its course.

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

WWE Raw thoughts: 4/8/13

As promised, Monday was the Raw after WrestleMania 29, which means it's time to begin my WWE vs. TNA show reviews for the 2013-14 season!

For the sake of maintaining free time, I will only be reviewing the 'A' shows of each company (e.g. WWE Raw and Impact Wrestling). If the time comes where the World Heavyweight Championship becomes exclusively shown on SmackDown again, I'll add it, but as it stands, I can see the top flight champions just fine on the main shows and anything of consequence on other programming winds up shown in recaps anyway.

If something of note happens on WWE SmackDown, Main Event or Slam, or on TNA Xplosion or whatever the hell else programming TNA tries to create, I will make note of it and review it in a separate blog. For now, though, let's discuss Raw.

I'll rate each segment on a 1-10 scale, award/remove bonus points for things like future booking, and end with a show average. Here we go!


John Cena opening promo: I was definitely not a fan of how predictable WrestleMania felt this year, and evidently this crowd wasn't either. They got on Cena from the start, but honestly, it brought out some of his better work. He used his humor specifically to get a rise out of the hostile crowd and was practically in a smug heel role. I also loved when Mark Henry came out, but the segment lost ground when Booker T killed the momentum with his matchmaking. Cena could have made that suggestion or it could have been set with Henry backstage. It just shut everyone down after getting hyped for a title match. Overall, not a bad start. 6/10

Big E Langston (w/AJ & Ziggler) v. Daniel Bryan/Kurt Warner: Short, sweet and to the point. Langston looked good in the (very short match) and kudos to AJ for taking a chest shot like a champ during the entrances. Also, Kurt Warner was here. Nice! I won't rate this very high because matches under 3 minutes don't get rated here and we spent much of the time hyping another program, so I'll go 5.2/10.

Remember when people thought this belt would become
important again? Me either.
Intercontinental Championship: Miz (c) v. Wade Barrett: Barrett's loss of the title at Mania's pre-show was clearly the equivalent of a house show title change. It got a cheap pop to warm up the crowd (real successful there, WWE) and is being forgotten almost immediately. The match itself was solid, and the crowd was into it, so I was ok with it. I rate the match itself as 2.5 stars (out of 5), and anything above four stars on free TV is a 10 for me, so that would make the segment worth 6.25/10.

Vickie/Booker shenanigans and Zeb Colter/Jack Swagger's racism: I like the idea of Orton and Sheamus wanting the same thing, like the idea of feuding GMs, and was bored by the setup. Also, I hate this Swagger/Colter b.s. I'm not sure who keeps insisting on these two, but they're boring at best and offensive at worst. Let's move on. 3/10

Alberto Del Rio v. Swagger/Colter in 2-on-1 handicap: Not even nonstop chants for Ziggler made me care here. Swagger is just dull to watch and I want this feud to die. Jack Swagger is NOT Kurt Angle and Del Rio is NOT Rey Mysterio. Stop trying to revive that awesome feud in this ghastly form. The match was 2 stars but loses points due to utter annoyance. 4.8/10

Ziggler cashes in Money in the Bank... World Heavyweight Championship: Alberto Del Rio (c) v. Dolph Ziggler: These were the best few minutes of the show. The New Jersey crowd popped like the Attitude Era for Ziggler and treated the whole match with real emotion. Ziggler winning felt like a real accomplishment, the way ALL World title victories should be. I've never been huge on Ziggler, but he's grown on me in the last few months, and I'm glad to see him win. The match gets no rating, but this segment gets a 10/10 with a bonus .5 for sheer awesomeness.

Undertaker promo/Shield invasion/Daniel Bryan becomes Spike Dudley of the Brothers of Destruction: Undertaker stuff is great when it's on and I liked how this clearly is setting up Hell No vs. The Shield. I still say they need a main eventer to become a real force, but this was good for what it was. 7.5/10

CoBro/R-Truth v. 3MB: I have nothing to say. This was a jobber-fest and no one was into it. Apparently 3MB is replacing the Divas as the bathroom break. Match was 1.5 stars. 3.75/10

Orton and Sheamus fight for Big Show's honor/Vickie and Booker say IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT YOUR TWITTER POLL THINKS!: Why was there a Raw-Active poll here? Did they go in with the plan that Sheamus would win and when he didn't Booker and Vickie just made up something on the fly? Wasn't Booker just being goaded into a power struggle with Vickie? Kudos to teasing someone (probably Orton) turning heel, but it's buried under other questions of basic logic. 3.75/10

Randy Orton v. Sheamus  New Jersey would rather put ring hands, vendors, free agents and the deceased over before what's going on in the ring: Perhaps WWE should have realized a slow, plodding match between guys who have wrestled many, MANY times before would not go over well among the fine people of New Jersey. I feel this match probably should have been cut short once they started doing the wave. My personal favorite chant (though only because the one for the pretzel/ice cream vendors came during commercial) was after Big Show came out, beat up both men, threw two announce chairs at the ring, and then walked out to boos because he wouldn't throw "One more chair! One more chair!" I'll talk more about the crowd at the end. The match was fine, and was probably 3 stars before the beatdown (which will cost the segment), but the crowd is the story here and it deserves points. Let's just say 9/10 for the whole spectacle? Ok then.

Fandango v. ... Who cares who he wrestled? The crowd is dancing! Fandango wrestled Kofi Kingston and Jericho beat up Fandango, but let's be honest. The only thing people cared about was the crowd singing along to Fandango's theme song and dancing in the stands. The Jericho brawl did run a little long, so I guess the whole thing gets 5.5/10.

Paul Heyman speaks/The match teased for Mania that Vince decided should be cut to make room for more video packages: You have to give Paul Heyman credit, even this asylum of nuts keeps quiet when he speaks. He gave some nice teasers before the Rhodes Scholars/Bella Twins faced Tons of Funk. The match was pretty solid, though too short to be anything good or even rate-able. I guess as a whole this section gets 6/10.

John Cena v. Mark Henry/Ryback must feast... on GOLD: Cena and Henry had a forgettable 3-minute embarrassment before Henry inducted Cena into the Hall of Pain (cause THAT'S WHAT HE DO!). Ryback makes the save before beating up Cena for trying to get in on his chants (much to the thrill of the NJ fans). If this was meant to be a heel turn for Ryback, it failed miserably because this crowd LOVED it. The match was a pathetic 1.25 stars, but the thing gets mad points for the beatdowns, song-and-dance (which was still going, by the way) and feud setup brings the whole thing up to a 7.25/10.

Total: I'll just speak about the crowd briefly. Some reviewers weren't happy that they distracted from what was honestly the strongest match on the night before the Big Show's interference. I'd say sure, but please note that, again, that was the strongest match that night. Yeah, there were some nice moments, but the crowd paid to be entertained, and if they aren't then they have every right to make their presence felt.

Honestly, this was probably the best crowd to have after a WrestleMania like Sunday's card. Normal fans get so caught up in rooting interests, and Internet fans get so caught up in workrate and the business side that both sometimes forget that these programs exist to be entertaining. This crowd made sure WWE management knew they didn't find certain aspects of the product entertaining.

And they didn't do it like a West Coast crowd, who just stop paying attention and act bored the whole time. They didn't behave like the maniacs at the ECW Arena or Hammerstein ballroom and chastise the competitors for existing. They didn't go on profanity-laced tirades that would be censored out. They took note of something they liked, and when they weren't entertained, they said, "fine, we'll entertain ourselves! Good luck boring your audience with us around!"

That's what was great about last night's crowd. They made the show fun and made what has been a usually long-winded three hours feel like a re-watchable program. This show had a great Ziggler moment that is the true highlight of the night and red-hot reactions.

Averaged out, the whole thing is 6/10, but +.5 for a monumental title change and +.5 for the crowd brings the whole show to 7/10.

I'll do Impact Wrestling this Thursday night, and then I'll begin the "Good, Bad, and Ugly" column later this week, so stay tuned!

Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.