So this go-around, I'm actually able to make a fully informed statement on a pay-per-view, as my friends bought and recorded it. The Royal Rumble card can be described as the PPV where WWE tried to do everything in its power to surprise us on a card where nothing was that surprising.
The World Heavyweight Championship opened the show, which is always unsettling, though I kind of figured it would. I liked the idea of Alberto Del Rio's rematch with Big Show also being a Last Man Standing match because it makes his wins look like they might be stipulation-based. This is the only way a build to a regular singles match out of a gimmick singles match makes any sense.
The match worked well simply because Big Show knows how to make the LMS stipulation really compelling. The finish, well, it was stupid. Just like when John Cena used the same duct tape trick to keep Batista down, it strikes me as a cheat because it's not actually limiting the person's ability to stand.
Additionally, the finish feels like something a cowardly heel should be doing, not someone who plays off as a fighting champion. It's not as bad as the Batista-Cena version since ADR recently was in the cowardly heel role, but it did diminish a good match. Still, it's worth 3 stars.
The World Tag Title match felt like a by-the-numbers match with minimal PPV quality (about 2.25-2.5 stars). Clearly, all four men were saving their strength for the Rumble, so it makes me wonder why they even bothered with the match.
Oh yeah, it's because the Divas can't carry an 8-minute match due to inhumanly awful signings, training and booking. Sara Del Rey needs to bring the NXT girls up soon.
The Rumble match itself was its usual awesome, almost-four-star self. Jericho was an excellent surprise, Bo Dallas made big noise in his debut and Kofi's chair routine was awesome.
My biggest two complaints are about the lack of real surprise entrants after Y2J (Goldust, Godfather and rookie Bo Dallas were all) and the predictability of the finish. The whole thing actually lost drama as contenders got thrown out.
The final six were Cena, Randy Orton, Sheamus, Dolph Ziggler, Y2J and Ryback, so it's clear WWE knew that they lacked any real drama so tried putting the most credible guys in at the end to throw some doubt.
But then the iron men from the start of the match (Ziggler and Y2J) were gone, ending all hope of Ziggler's belt unification tease (seriously, stop talking about it if you won't pull the trigger, WWE!), and the SmackDown superstars who could have gone for the WHC also went out, leaving a Cena-Ryback showdown with the finish as a foregone conclusion. Both would have gone for the WWE Championship, so there was no way Ryback was winning.
Overall, nice match, but the end result should not become an increasing certainty as you go.
Then the main event: This. Was. AWESOME. Unlike the Rumble match, Rock and CM Punk didn't have to do the title change that night, so there was some uncertainty.
Both men looked to be in excellent condition and it was a great watch, probably the best match on the card (I'd say 4 stars out of 5). What keeps it from being a classic was the nonsensical restarting of the match. There had to be a better way to do this. Masked assailant? Foot on the rope? Anything? Oh well.
I have no issues with the matches on this card, the card itself, or even the booking decisions on the card. My issue is that I can see the payoff to these decisions a mile away.
I have three things that sell matches to me on a PPV card: Quality potential (will the match be entertaining in the ring), urgency (a first-time, blowoff or last time ever match) and unpredictability (booking has made it that at least two different results are logical and viable). Name value means a lot to some, but I see the names in the build-up so it's not huge.
The problem with setting up Cena-Rock II is that it fails in all three categories. It's not a first-time match and I don't buy Rock will never return, so urgency is out. The crowd really pushed the first Cena-Rock clash to a high-level, and I don't see that happening again, so I don't see high quality potential.
And the result is a foregone conclusion. Rock is leaving for a while again, so he can't keep the belt. He can't just beat all the top active talent without burying the product. And he's facing the top guy (who never loses clean) who he's already beaten clean. There is literally no incentive for me to pay for this match.
Add in that there's no way Brock Lesnar will beat HHH again in that almost certain-to-happen match, and Undertaker's win is pretty much guaranteed, the most important match that meets any criteria is the WHC match. I can't justify paying any amount of money on a PPV if there is NO drama to it.
Luckily, while the payoffs at WrestleMania don't look like something to pay for, the build-up on the free shows looks like it'll be great. I've never been more upset that I had to work than last night, as Raw was on my old college campus 20 minutes away.
I can't seriously believe I missed seeing WWE Champion Rock, Y2J, and the announcement of Trish Stratus' Hall of Fame induction live. Then again, in two live shows I've seen the CM Punk pipe bomb, Big Show going through a steel cage wall, Shawn Michaels, Jack Swagger cashing in Money in the Bank and Undertaker the week after retiring HBK. (WWE likes to make a big deal out of Vegas shows, huh?)
The build to Mania looks like it's going to be great. Since Rock clearly won't enter an Elimination Chamber, it appears The Shield will go in with Cena, Sheamus and Ryback. To accomplish what, I'm not sure (Cena's Rumble shot, maybe?).
Y2J and Ziggler appear to be moving back toward a feud at Mania, so there may be at least one quality match. And I loved that Big Show got retribution for that B.S. ADR duct tape thing.
Rock and Punk are clearly setting up a match at the Chamber PPV, and this excites me. Aside from the awesome promos that will take up the next three weeks, this sets up the prospect of maybe a dirty finish that turns the Cena rematch into a Triple Threat with Punk, Rock and Cena. It would add some uncertainty and I think they could pull off a good three-way match.
There were drawbacks on this show, though. The thing with Tensai must NEVER be spoken of again. Cody Rhodes got an unnecessary squashing, which was annoying. And you know a match is going over horribly when the announcers have to apologize for it and swear that "it gets better from here" like they had to do with the Divas. (Seriously, this HAS to build to Sara Del Rey and the NXT Divas running in and overthrowing this forsaken turd of a division. Please let it be so!)
And this is really a nitpick, but did anyone else think that Cena's promo was supposed to originally end the show, but they moved it before Rock and Punk so it would get more interest? Because he clearly references Rock and Punk being his possible WWE title match opponents before any rematch was set up. Not a huge deal, but it raised my Person's Eyebrow.
But yeah, the Wrestlemania build should be awesome, even if at this point I'm just hoping WWE will do something to surprise me. Here's hoping for a good card in Jersey!
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
After years of activity, this blog is being folded into the main blog. If there is something of wresting note, check out the main blog.
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Friday, January 18, 2013
Who would the AFC/NFC conference championship teams be in WWE? (2012-13, Year 3)
This is probably my favorite blog to do every year because it combines two of my favorite things: NFL Conference Championship weekend and pro wrestling.
For the third year in a row, I will be revealing which WWE Superstar's personality best reflects the teams playing on Sunday.
Now, this year's games feature three of the four teams that played last year. Does that mean I'll be doing the same wrestlers as last year? Of course not!
First of all, one of the wrestlers is not active anymore, so he can't be used. Secondly, the New England as a team fits a different wrestler this time, and Big Show's recent booking makes it so he no longer fits with Baltimore.
So, let's get to it!
Atlanta Falcons: Dolph Ziggler
Of all the teams, this was probably the easiest to piece together. Ziggler's critiques and Atlanta's critiques almost parallel each other.
For years, they were highly touted even though many were unsure of their longevity. And in the past year they have gotten a hot hand and suddenly become a real commodity.
However, much like Ziggler, Atlanta has the issue of never being able to win in a big spot.
Atlanta has only been to one Super Bowl in franchise history, which only happened because an automatic kicker in Minnesota had a brain fart on the winning kick.
Likewise, Ziggler has only held a World title once – when he had it handed to him after Vickie Guerrero vacated it. In both cases, a true champion (Orton for Ziggler, the 1998 Broncos for Atlanta) put them down in a rather non-competitive title clash.
They've each had a signature moment recently. Ziggler won Money in the Bank to clinch a title shot, and the Falcons won their first playoff game under Mike Smith and Matt Ryan to reach the NFC title game.
And just as Atlanta has shown a history of coming up flat in big games (Giants game last year ring a bell?), Ziggler has proven incapable of beating Sheamus or John Cena, regardless of the volume of help.
Both Atlanta and Ziggler have much to prove, and the Falcons get the next chance to break their mold. We shall see what happens.
San Francisco 49ers: Daniel Bryan
Much like when Chris Jericho was their contemporary last year, Daniel Bryan represents San Fran's technical brilliance.
Bryan's long history of winning the top title in every company he enters mirrors San Fran's dominant runs of old.
At the same time, the Niners' recent blunders and failures can draw comparisons to Bryan's fall from the main event (after an 18-second Sheamus beatdown and countless losses to CM Punk) and trip to "anger management."
But like that anger management, the hiring of Jim Harbaugh has changed the culture of the Niners, as Bryan's move into a tag team with Kane has revitalized the crowd's focus on him.
Bryan has been on a roll and is back in the driver's seat of a division, as San Fran has been.
And much like Bryan, who dominates through perfectly executed techniques because of a lack of size, the 49ers show their flashes of brilliance through expert defensive play-calling, excellent personnel decisions, receivers and running backs executing and a dynamic QB whose ability to run or pass mimic Bryan's ability to be a high-flyer or a technical ground submission guy.
It's that wide versatility and completeness of their games that make San Francisco and Daniel Bryan an excellent match for each other.
Baltimore Ravens: Kane
I'll admit: I had a REALLY hard time coming up with this one. I had firmly expected Denver and had only two wrestlers to really choose from there
Here, it was hard to come across a good wrestler to match the Ravens. I originally thought it would be Wade Barrett in that Barrett has been on a mission to move up the card and has provided a "Barrett Barrage" whose force is taking out high-level guys like Randy Orton.
But then I realized that much like Bryan, Kane has been revitalized by his return to tag team action. His ability to talk has energized the fans into believing he's a real player again.
That is very much the same thing going on with Ray Lewis and the Ravens. After floundering for weeks, Lewis' return and announced retirement has brought back the Ravens back from oblivion.
There's been talk that Lewis/Kane were too old or the accumulated injuries have left them a non-factor. There's been constant criticism of the work of Joe Flacco/Kane's recent matches. But the recent work of both the Ravens' key players and Kane have brought them back into the forefront and make them believable as a threat for titles again.
And much like John Harbaugh has his brother Jim in San Fran, Kane's brotherly, constant struggle relationship with Daniel Bryan could be some of the best stuff on television. I look forward to Team Hell No's antics on Raw like I'm looking forward to a possible clash between Baltimore and San Francisco.
And where Bryan/San Fran bring the high-flying and technical aspect to the pair, Kane and the Ravens bring the power and energy. And if you don't believe that, ask Peyton Manning about the Baltimore pass rush, or Indianapolis about Baltimore's energy with Ray Lewis egging them on.
New England Patriots: John Cena
In all seriousness, there's really no one else who could match who the Pats really are this year.
John Cena, much like the Pats, is a Massachusetts-based talent who almost always is hanging around the main event of the show. But this goes much deeper than just location.
Cena, a multi-time champion, has not held the top title in a significant period of time (about 18 months), like the Patriots (eight years). They each have a rival who seems to have their number for one reason or another (Cena - CM Punk, Pats - Giants). Heck, they both just lost the game they "had to win" for their legacies this past year (Cena - Rock at WrestleMania, Pats - Giants at Super Bowl)
Each has made a habit of doing something that is considered a difficult feat even though they've done it basically every time they've met and it's becoming a joke (Cena - hitting the FU/AA on the Big Show, Pats - eliminating Peyton Manning). But this goes (somehow) even deeper.
Both have effectively been given the keys to the mansion by their league and don't take any real hit when they have had serious issues in the past (Cena - very obviously cheating on his wife with Divas/other wrestlers' girlfriends, Patriots - Spygate) The Patriots team is publicly thought of as a player considered a sex object and passionate about his sport despite critiques (some legit, some embellished) that he is largely limited (byproduct of a system, can't throw outside pocket, folds up when hit, etc.).
Brady and Cena likewise are currently married to or dating very hot women (Brady & Giselle, Cena & Nikki Bella).
And lastly, but most importantly, they are polarizing. They have their passionate supporters and intense haters. Some respect the man (men) but can't stand the arrogance of the fans or the belief in a "SuperCena" or "SuperTom" who must be totally obliterated by an apocalyptic explosion in order to lose to ANYONE clean and with dignity.
John Cena is the Patriots embodied, and it's only fitting that the Newbury, Mass. native reflects the culture of annoyance that his region's football team so clearly drives.
My genuine rooting interest is that I get the Harbaugh Bowl of Baltimore vs. San Francisco, but as we've seen with Kane last February (and Ziggler on Monday), if there's one thing a John Cena type is good at, it's winning a match they have no right to win and driving an entire swath of fans into a blind rage.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
For the third year in a row, I will be revealing which WWE Superstar's personality best reflects the teams playing on Sunday.
Now, this year's games feature three of the four teams that played last year. Does that mean I'll be doing the same wrestlers as last year? Of course not!
First of all, one of the wrestlers is not active anymore, so he can't be used. Secondly, the New England as a team fits a different wrestler this time, and Big Show's recent booking makes it so he no longer fits with Baltimore.
So, let's get to it!
Atlanta Falcons: Dolph Ziggler
Of all the teams, this was probably the easiest to piece together. Ziggler's critiques and Atlanta's critiques almost parallel each other.
For years, they were highly touted even though many were unsure of their longevity. And in the past year they have gotten a hot hand and suddenly become a real commodity.
However, much like Ziggler, Atlanta has the issue of never being able to win in a big spot.
Atlanta has only been to one Super Bowl in franchise history, which only happened because an automatic kicker in Minnesota had a brain fart on the winning kick.
They've each had a signature moment recently. Ziggler won Money in the Bank to clinch a title shot, and the Falcons won their first playoff game under Mike Smith and Matt Ryan to reach the NFC title game.
And just as Atlanta has shown a history of coming up flat in big games (Giants game last year ring a bell?), Ziggler has proven incapable of beating Sheamus or John Cena, regardless of the volume of help.
Both Atlanta and Ziggler have much to prove, and the Falcons get the next chance to break their mold. We shall see what happens.
San Francisco 49ers: Daniel Bryan
Much like when Chris Jericho was their contemporary last year, Daniel Bryan represents San Fran's technical brilliance.
Bryan's long history of winning the top title in every company he enters mirrors San Fran's dominant runs of old.
At the same time, the Niners' recent blunders and failures can draw comparisons to Bryan's fall from the main event (after an 18-second Sheamus beatdown and countless losses to CM Punk) and trip to "anger management."
But like that anger management, the hiring of Jim Harbaugh has changed the culture of the Niners, as Bryan's move into a tag team with Kane has revitalized the crowd's focus on him.
Bryan has been on a roll and is back in the driver's seat of a division, as San Fran has been.
And much like Bryan, who dominates through perfectly executed techniques because of a lack of size, the 49ers show their flashes of brilliance through expert defensive play-calling, excellent personnel decisions, receivers and running backs executing and a dynamic QB whose ability to run or pass mimic Bryan's ability to be a high-flyer or a technical ground submission guy.
It's that wide versatility and completeness of their games that make San Francisco and Daniel Bryan an excellent match for each other.
Baltimore Ravens: Kane
I'll admit: I had a REALLY hard time coming up with this one. I had firmly expected Denver and had only two wrestlers to really choose from there
Here, it was hard to come across a good wrestler to match the Ravens. I originally thought it would be Wade Barrett in that Barrett has been on a mission to move up the card and has provided a "Barrett Barrage" whose force is taking out high-level guys like Randy Orton.
But then I realized that much like Bryan, Kane has been revitalized by his return to tag team action. His ability to talk has energized the fans into believing he's a real player again.
That is very much the same thing going on with Ray Lewis and the Ravens. After floundering for weeks, Lewis' return and announced retirement has brought back the Ravens back from oblivion.
There's been talk that Lewis/Kane were too old or the accumulated injuries have left them a non-factor. There's been constant criticism of the work of Joe Flacco/Kane's recent matches. But the recent work of both the Ravens' key players and Kane have brought them back into the forefront and make them believable as a threat for titles again.
And much like John Harbaugh has his brother Jim in San Fran, Kane's brotherly, constant struggle relationship with Daniel Bryan could be some of the best stuff on television. I look forward to Team Hell No's antics on Raw like I'm looking forward to a possible clash between Baltimore and San Francisco.
And where Bryan/San Fran bring the high-flying and technical aspect to the pair, Kane and the Ravens bring the power and energy. And if you don't believe that, ask Peyton Manning about the Baltimore pass rush, or Indianapolis about Baltimore's energy with Ray Lewis egging them on.
New England Patriots: John Cena
In all seriousness, there's really no one else who could match who the Pats really are this year.
John Cena, much like the Pats, is a Massachusetts-based talent who almost always is hanging around the main event of the show. But this goes much deeper than just location.
Cena, a multi-time champion, has not held the top title in a significant period of time (about 18 months), like the Patriots (eight years). They each have a rival who seems to have their number for one reason or another (Cena - CM Punk, Pats - Giants). Heck, they both just lost the game they "had to win" for their legacies this past year (Cena - Rock at WrestleMania, Pats - Giants at Super Bowl)
Each has made a habit of doing something that is considered a difficult feat even though they've done it basically every time they've met and it's becoming a joke (Cena - hitting the FU/AA on the Big Show, Pats - eliminating Peyton Manning). But this goes (somehow) even deeper.
Both have effectively been given the keys to the mansion by their league and don't take any real hit when they have had serious issues in the past (Cena - very obviously cheating on his wife with Divas/other wrestlers' girlfriends, Patriots - Spygate) The Patriots team is publicly thought of as a player considered a sex object and passionate about his sport despite critiques (some legit, some embellished) that he is largely limited (byproduct of a system, can't throw outside pocket, folds up when hit, etc.).
Brady and Cena likewise are currently married to or dating very hot women (Brady & Giselle, Cena & Nikki Bella).
And lastly, but most importantly, they are polarizing. They have their passionate supporters and intense haters. Some respect the man (men) but can't stand the arrogance of the fans or the belief in a "SuperCena" or "SuperTom" who must be totally obliterated by an apocalyptic explosion in order to lose to ANYONE clean and with dignity.
John Cena is the Patriots embodied, and it's only fitting that the Newbury, Mass. native reflects the culture of annoyance that his region's football team so clearly drives.
My genuine rooting interest is that I get the Harbaugh Bowl of Baltimore vs. San Francisco, but as we've seen with Kane last February (and Ziggler on Monday), if there's one thing a John Cena type is good at, it's winning a match they have no right to win and driving an entire swath of fans into a blind rage.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
TNA Genesis PPV thoughts
I have to give TNA Wrestling credit: They've finally made a good call with their pay-per-view system.
After years of doing one card a month despite the fact that only about three sold enough to do a reasonable profit, TNA is cutting down to four legitimate PPV cards a year.
In order to seemingly meet their PPV contractual demands, they are also doing seven taped $15 cards. Incredibly, this too is not a stupid idea.
For one, if they sell horribly, they can be dropped in the next negotiation. But in practice, cards that showcase the tag division, X Division, Knockouts, etc. are a good way to showcase talent.
There are two really big benefits that also need to be considered. One is that taped cards can be purchased throughout the month without the results being anymore spoiled than the first airing. Once they're out of the PPV rotation, Spike could air them as TNA specials to help push the company as well.
The other is that these shows take place OUTSIDE TNA's storylines. This means that TNA can take booking risks they wouldn't normally take and give an element of uncertainty to cards, which will be especially handy in the card that revives the Ultimate X Cup and creates a new World Cup of Wrestling.
But while the non-canon cards actually have me interested in gimmick PPVs where the canon WWE gimmick cards upset me, TNA's first canon "Big Four" card was... disappointing.
[PLEASE note I am only basing this off of the way TNA has sold the card and the booking decisions of the matches. I have NOT watched the card in its entirety and can not judge the card on its overall quality because of it. This is merely my thoughts on what they tried to accomplish from a detached perspective.]
This might as well have been described as "The Card Where the Buck was Passed to 'Later On.'" No titles changed hands and no real storylines were advanced, but most importantly, it felt like a constant commercial for the future.
If you're cutting down to only four cards a year and increasing the price on all four, then you'd better make those cards 'must-see' events. I realize that TNA was still escaping the one-a-month cycle, but the whole card may as well have been simulated in GM Mode of the old "SmackDown vs. Raw" series.
There was a gauntlet match for a Knockouts Title shot in the future, a match for a World title shot at the end of the month, and even a match to determine an X Division challenger for later in the night. I get looking toward the future, but you're not really giving these matches a 'must-see' feel to them.
Joseph Park had a non-title clash with TV champ Devon that advanced nothing and really makes you wonder if they have a plan for when they're going to reveal him as Abyss. Samoa Joe and Mr Anderson had... a match. Oh, and Sting faced Doc in a match that was hyped for weeks and accomplished, you guessed it, nothing of consequence.
Only the World Tag Title and World Title had matches that had an urgent feel (fitting they opened and closed the show). The tag title match had a finish that made sense but has left me wondering exactly who is going to be left to feud with Chavo and Hernandez in this division.
The World Title match was the only match I've seen (I work Sundays so can only watch matches when I have access to taped versions. I usually only sit through the main events, MOTN and any match over an average of 3.25 stars, and this was the only match that met any of the categories), and it was really good, although they rushed the second fall to come too close to the first.
I honestly am not a Jeff Hardy as champ fan, but he's at least made the main events entertaining. So in conclusion, Lockdown's build better set up some real conclusions after that.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
After years of doing one card a month despite the fact that only about three sold enough to do a reasonable profit, TNA is cutting down to four legitimate PPV cards a year.
In order to seemingly meet their PPV contractual demands, they are also doing seven taped $15 cards. Incredibly, this too is not a stupid idea.
For one, if they sell horribly, they can be dropped in the next negotiation. But in practice, cards that showcase the tag division, X Division, Knockouts, etc. are a good way to showcase talent.
There are two really big benefits that also need to be considered. One is that taped cards can be purchased throughout the month without the results being anymore spoiled than the first airing. Once they're out of the PPV rotation, Spike could air them as TNA specials to help push the company as well.
The other is that these shows take place OUTSIDE TNA's storylines. This means that TNA can take booking risks they wouldn't normally take and give an element of uncertainty to cards, which will be especially handy in the card that revives the Ultimate X Cup and creates a new World Cup of Wrestling.
But while the non-canon cards actually have me interested in gimmick PPVs where the canon WWE gimmick cards upset me, TNA's first canon "Big Four" card was... disappointing.
[PLEASE note I am only basing this off of the way TNA has sold the card and the booking decisions of the matches. I have NOT watched the card in its entirety and can not judge the card on its overall quality because of it. This is merely my thoughts on what they tried to accomplish from a detached perspective.]
This might as well have been described as "The Card Where the Buck was Passed to 'Later On.'" No titles changed hands and no real storylines were advanced, but most importantly, it felt like a constant commercial for the future.
If you're cutting down to only four cards a year and increasing the price on all four, then you'd better make those cards 'must-see' events. I realize that TNA was still escaping the one-a-month cycle, but the whole card may as well have been simulated in GM Mode of the old "SmackDown vs. Raw" series.
There was a gauntlet match for a Knockouts Title shot in the future, a match for a World title shot at the end of the month, and even a match to determine an X Division challenger for later in the night. I get looking toward the future, but you're not really giving these matches a 'must-see' feel to them.
Joseph Park had a non-title clash with TV champ Devon that advanced nothing and really makes you wonder if they have a plan for when they're going to reveal him as Abyss. Samoa Joe and Mr Anderson had... a match. Oh, and Sting faced Doc in a match that was hyped for weeks and accomplished, you guessed it, nothing of consequence.
Only the World Tag Title and World Title had matches that had an urgent feel (fitting they opened and closed the show). The tag title match had a finish that made sense but has left me wondering exactly who is going to be left to feud with Chavo and Hernandez in this division.
The World Title match was the only match I've seen (I work Sundays so can only watch matches when I have access to taped versions. I usually only sit through the main events, MOTN and any match over an average of 3.25 stars, and this was the only match that met any of the categories), and it was really good, although they rushed the second fall to come too close to the first.
I honestly am not a Jeff Hardy as champ fan, but he's at least made the main events entertaining. So in conclusion, Lockdown's build better set up some real conclusions after that.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Thursday, January 10, 2013
TNA embarking on new PPV venture
UPDATE: The TNA One Night Only cards will still be PPV, but will only cost $15. Non-Bound For Glory Big 4 cards will be $35 and BFG will be $45.
Dixie Carter linked via Facebook a press release that Impact Wrestling/TNA is going to be changing the way they do pay-per-views.
Following Genesis next weekend, the company will take a month off before the Lockdown card in March. From there, they will do a series of "One Night Only" cards on the first Friday of each month.
Basically, it's the "In Your House" concept from 1990s WWF, except from what I can tell, the ONO cards will be PPV-caliber supercards broadcast for free on Spike TV. This raises the question of why you're running the taped PPV card on a Friday and not a Sunday other than to see if you could stick it to SmackDown's increasingly anemic ratings, but whatever.
Only TNA's Big Four cards will be on PPV now. So you will only pay for Bound for Glory, Slammiversary, Lockdown and... Genesis? Why not Final Resolution? It has a perfect name for a year-end card and could be a follow of the Starcade tradition.
I guess TNA figures Genesis could kick off the PPV year, leaving BFG as their year-end spectacular. And I suppose December is a crowded month already with UFC's year-end card and WWE TLC.
Overall, I like the move and it instantly makes me want to watch Impact Wrestling since it is now less of a financial burden to be a fan of them vs. being a fan of WWE. That said, it's a quality vs. quantity thing, so TNA better make freaking sure their quality actually makes fans question why they're shelling out $50 a month for WWE.
Then again, with WWE's plans for 'Mania being teased, that may not be too hard as long as this Brooke Hogan B.S. ends soon.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Dixie Carter linked via Facebook a press release that Impact Wrestling/TNA is going to be changing the way they do pay-per-views.
Following Genesis next weekend, the company will take a month off before the Lockdown card in March. From there, they will do a series of "One Night Only" cards on the first Friday of each month.
Basically, it's the "In Your House" concept from 1990s WWF, except from what I can tell, the ONO cards will be PPV-caliber supercards broadcast for free on Spike TV. This raises the question of why you're running the taped PPV card on a Friday and not a Sunday other than to see if you could stick it to SmackDown's increasingly anemic ratings, but whatever.
Only TNA's Big Four cards will be on PPV now. So you will only pay for Bound for Glory, Slammiversary, Lockdown and... Genesis? Why not Final Resolution? It has a perfect name for a year-end card and could be a follow of the Starcade tradition.
I guess TNA figures Genesis could kick off the PPV year, leaving BFG as their year-end spectacular. And I suppose December is a crowded month already with UFC's year-end card and WWE TLC.
Overall, I like the move and it instantly makes me want to watch Impact Wrestling since it is now less of a financial burden to be a fan of them vs. being a fan of WWE. That said, it's a quality vs. quantity thing, so TNA better make freaking sure their quality actually makes fans question why they're shelling out $50 a month for WWE.
Then again, with WWE's plans for 'Mania being teased, that may not be too hard as long as this Brooke Hogan B.S. ends soon.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Wrestlemania projected matches (POSSIBLE SPOILERS)
First time on this blog this year, and I'm just going to point out that 411mania.com has gotten the rumored four main events for this year's Wrestlemania.
To save you the time of linking, here they are:
WWE Title (Raw World) - Rock-Cena II
World Heavyweight Title (SD World) - Sheamus-Randy Orton
The Streak: Undertaker v. CM Punk
Triple H v. Brock Lesnar
I am not excited by this prospect.
If you insist on having Rock face Cena, you should have done it this month. Set up a first encounter for WM, but then that would involve John Cena not being in the main event of WM. (Can't have that, can we?)
Moreover, it's clear that Rock won't make Cena job twice, especially with the title on the line and Rock having no intention of continuing to compete after the card. So what's my incentive? I know a result if this winds up being the action.
SmackDown I know wants to make this the main feud and I have no real issues with it. I'm more interested in which one takes the title, how Orton turns heel, and whether Ziggler gets involved in the picture or not.
Again, I don't like that I know the result of the match already and I doubt Punk is the one to end the Streak. If he did, I'd admire the heck out of WWE for having the guts to do so, but I don't feel a real threat here.
Lastly, Brock and H is fine. I'm just no more interested now than I was at SummerSlam, but at least it doesn't end the card this time.
Obviously, these can change, but I really hope there's a better plan in store and this is just a mislead. We'll see though.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
To save you the time of linking, here they are:
WWE Title (Raw World) - Rock-Cena II
World Heavyweight Title (SD World) - Sheamus-Randy Orton
The Streak: Undertaker v. CM Punk
Triple H v. Brock Lesnar
I am not excited by this prospect.
If you insist on having Rock face Cena, you should have done it this month. Set up a first encounter for WM, but then that would involve John Cena not being in the main event of WM. (Can't have that, can we?)
Moreover, it's clear that Rock won't make Cena job twice, especially with the title on the line and Rock having no intention of continuing to compete after the card. So what's my incentive? I know a result if this winds up being the action.
SmackDown I know wants to make this the main feud and I have no real issues with it. I'm more interested in which one takes the title, how Orton turns heel, and whether Ziggler gets involved in the picture or not.
Again, I don't like that I know the result of the match already and I doubt Punk is the one to end the Streak. If he did, I'd admire the heck out of WWE for having the guts to do so, but I don't feel a real threat here.
Lastly, Brock and H is fine. I'm just no more interested now than I was at SummerSlam, but at least it doesn't end the card this time.
Obviously, these can change, but I really hope there's a better plan in store and this is just a mislead. We'll see though.
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Monday, October 29, 2012
The Good, Bad and Ugly: World Title booking and Hell in a Cell
Vince Russo once made the argument that championships are nothing more than props – objects that can be used in feuds to spark/build them.
What a load of crap.
Yes, it's true that titles in a staged sport mean less than titles in legitimate sport from a competitive standpoint because it's the decision of people who aren't the competitors. However, the mark of being the top of a division/company is a true honor that in storyline terms is competed for with full force and execution.
It is a symbol of reaching a point of prominence in the company. I disagree with many things Russo has said in the past, but that remains the most irritating in my view.
I make a point of keeping track of titles that I believe to be World or near-World titles and seeing how those belts are being booked. To this point, using my formula (which I'm sure I'll one day post), I've only been able to pin down three active World titles: WWE Raw (WWE World Title), WWE SmackDown (WWE World Heavyweight Title) and TNA (TNA World Heavyweight Title).
Impact Wrestling just recently changed hands with their belt. Former champion Jeff Hardy won the belt at Bound For Glory against Austin Aries, and has already defended it once against Kurt Angle.
TNA has done a good job at making their belt seem more relevant in recent months. Robert Roode held it for nine months and appeared to be well on his way to completing his year-long feud with James Storm at BFG for the belt.
But plans changed when Aries set the precedent of the X Division Champion getting a shot at the belt at Destination X. Aries became such a hot commodity that they had to get the belt on him.
The plans for TNA recently have been better if you exclude one or two storylines that tend to become WAY too complex during each show cycle. One of the biggest issues I had was this recent title change.
I understand its purpose: To keep the top merchandise seller from leaving. But by turning Aries heel a week before the title match, it messed with the match's dynamic, and people weren't solidly behind Hardy.
Luckily, both talents are good enough to sell it, but it was a hiccup that I'm not sure worked. If something compelling comes out of it, though, I'll overlook it.
The problem with both major companies is that I don't always believe the payoff will be that great. CM Punk's booking against Ryback at Hell in the Cell yesterday shows that.
If the company couldn't figure out a way to keep Punk's reign and Ryback's streak intact (which was difficult to do given the Cell gimmick), then why did you book yourself in that corner?
The finish of the match (which I'm spoiling here. Trust me, you don't want to buy this.) to have a corrupt referee hit Ryback in the nads to cost him the match evoked a terrible "Goldberg gets hit with a taser vs. Kevin Nash" vibe and led me to believe that this push is going to end up botched.
Punk had been asking that the match be canceled. This was remarkably simple to fix. Ryback gets mauled going to the entrance ramp. Vickie has to cancel the match. Cena was cleared, so he could have taken the shot. Or better yet, Ziggler, having opted against using his MITB contract that night, could call his shot and try for the WWE title, only to lose narrowly (or via corrupt ref if you wanted to test him as a face).
But instead WWE clearly blows the main event with hopes that Ryabck hitting a top-of-the-cell spot would compensate. WWE chose to go with the safe short-term payoff of Punk facing Rock instead of trying to vault a new superstar into the spotlight. Ugh.
This is contrasted with what had been a well-executed World Heavyweight Championship feud. Sheamus and Big Show had been comparing power for weeks and put on an amazing match with a legitimately surprising result. One quesiton, though: Why wasn't this in a cell?
This match could have used the cell perfectly and could have then closed out the show so that the PPV felt like it ended with a real finish. I don't care if you don't think these guys are draws or not. People already paid for the show! It doesn't matter which match is last so long as it was main-event caliber (WHC matches always are) and could provide closure to a show (the way the WWE title did NOT).
Overall, this show was botched heavily, and is little more than filler to Survivor Series. Good luck with the next three weeks of booking, WWE.
I'll close this first column installment (which is getting REALLY long), with how I will be formatting from here on out. I will give a Good (highlight of the night), Bad (lowlight) and Ugly (something unexpected - be it unexpectedly good, bad or bizarre) for the week's shows - in this case, just the Hell in a Cell PPV.
*For the record, I work during PPVs, so I only saw a few matches that hadn't yet been taken down and went with live reports for the rest (hence why Punk-Ryback isn't in this list).
Good: Sheamus v. Big Show (3.75 stars) - I already went into this, but the feud hyped this match well, and I was legitimately surprised they took the title off Sheamus when they did. It should open up some interesting feuds for the next couple of months, though. Good power match that really exceeded even my hopes.
Bad: Divas' Triple Threat (1 star) - The Divas won't be in all the time, only when they really stink up the joint. And this sucked the life out of the place. I'm glad they're advancing a real story, but these three did not seem to have a plan.
Ugly: US Title Match (2.5 stars) - Ahh, the US Title. The only place where an Eastern European defeats a Canadian acting like an Italian and then defends against a South African. This belt is almost a low-to-mid card belt now, well below even the IC title, but Justin Gabriel and Antonio Cesaro put out a good effort here. It was a match I think everyone wanted to skip, but it made for a compelling few minutes.
Overall, the show had some solid moments, but nothing stuck out in a good way. It felt like a waste of a card. Give it a 5 out of 10. It's a take it or leave it kind of card, just there to fill time, or in this case, SIX WEEKS of TV programming. (And yet, we somehow had an impromptu match and two on a week's notice. Go figure.)
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and Like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
What a load of crap.
Yes, it's true that titles in a staged sport mean less than titles in legitimate sport from a competitive standpoint because it's the decision of people who aren't the competitors. However, the mark of being the top of a division/company is a true honor that in storyline terms is competed for with full force and execution.
It is a symbol of reaching a point of prominence in the company. I disagree with many things Russo has said in the past, but that remains the most irritating in my view.
I make a point of keeping track of titles that I believe to be World or near-World titles and seeing how those belts are being booked. To this point, using my formula (which I'm sure I'll one day post), I've only been able to pin down three active World titles: WWE Raw (WWE World Title), WWE SmackDown (WWE World Heavyweight Title) and TNA (TNA World Heavyweight Title).
Impact Wrestling just recently changed hands with their belt. Former champion Jeff Hardy won the belt at Bound For Glory against Austin Aries, and has already defended it once against Kurt Angle.
TNA has done a good job at making their belt seem more relevant in recent months. Robert Roode held it for nine months and appeared to be well on his way to completing his year-long feud with James Storm at BFG for the belt.
But plans changed when Aries set the precedent of the X Division Champion getting a shot at the belt at Destination X. Aries became such a hot commodity that they had to get the belt on him.
![]() |
| People, this belt is NOT as bad as his Divas' Title ripoff. |
I understand its purpose: To keep the top merchandise seller from leaving. But by turning Aries heel a week before the title match, it messed with the match's dynamic, and people weren't solidly behind Hardy.
Luckily, both talents are good enough to sell it, but it was a hiccup that I'm not sure worked. If something compelling comes out of it, though, I'll overlook it.
The problem with both major companies is that I don't always believe the payoff will be that great. CM Punk's booking against Ryback at Hell in the Cell yesterday shows that.
If the company couldn't figure out a way to keep Punk's reign and Ryback's streak intact (which was difficult to do given the Cell gimmick), then why did you book yourself in that corner?
The finish of the match (which I'm spoiling here. Trust me, you don't want to buy this.) to have a corrupt referee hit Ryback in the nads to cost him the match evoked a terrible "Goldberg gets hit with a taser vs. Kevin Nash" vibe and led me to believe that this push is going to end up botched.
Punk had been asking that the match be canceled. This was remarkably simple to fix. Ryback gets mauled going to the entrance ramp. Vickie has to cancel the match. Cena was cleared, so he could have taken the shot. Or better yet, Ziggler, having opted against using his MITB contract that night, could call his shot and try for the WWE title, only to lose narrowly (or via corrupt ref if you wanted to test him as a face).
But instead WWE clearly blows the main event with hopes that Ryabck hitting a top-of-the-cell spot would compensate. WWE chose to go with the safe short-term payoff of Punk facing Rock instead of trying to vault a new superstar into the spotlight. Ugh.
This is contrasted with what had been a well-executed World Heavyweight Championship feud. Sheamus and Big Show had been comparing power for weeks and put on an amazing match with a legitimately surprising result. One quesiton, though: Why wasn't this in a cell?
This match could have used the cell perfectly and could have then closed out the show so that the PPV felt like it ended with a real finish. I don't care if you don't think these guys are draws or not. People already paid for the show! It doesn't matter which match is last so long as it was main-event caliber (WHC matches always are) and could provide closure to a show (the way the WWE title did NOT).
Overall, this show was botched heavily, and is little more than filler to Survivor Series. Good luck with the next three weeks of booking, WWE.
I'll close this first column installment (which is getting REALLY long), with how I will be formatting from here on out. I will give a Good (highlight of the night), Bad (lowlight) and Ugly (something unexpected - be it unexpectedly good, bad or bizarre) for the week's shows - in this case, just the Hell in a Cell PPV.
*For the record, I work during PPVs, so I only saw a few matches that hadn't yet been taken down and went with live reports for the rest (hence why Punk-Ryback isn't in this list).
Good: Sheamus v. Big Show (3.75 stars) - I already went into this, but the feud hyped this match well, and I was legitimately surprised they took the title off Sheamus when they did. It should open up some interesting feuds for the next couple of months, though. Good power match that really exceeded even my hopes.
Bad: Divas' Triple Threat (1 star) - The Divas won't be in all the time, only when they really stink up the joint. And this sucked the life out of the place. I'm glad they're advancing a real story, but these three did not seem to have a plan.
Ugly: US Title Match (2.5 stars) - Ahh, the US Title. The only place where an Eastern European defeats a Canadian acting like an Italian and then defends against a South African. This belt is almost a low-to-mid card belt now, well below even the IC title, but Justin Gabriel and Antonio Cesaro put out a good effort here. It was a match I think everyone wanted to skip, but it made for a compelling few minutes.
Overall, the show had some solid moments, but nothing stuck out in a good way. It felt like a waste of a card. Give it a 5 out of 10. It's a take it or leave it kind of card, just there to fill time, or in this case, SIX WEEKS of TV programming. (And yet, we somehow had an impromptu match and two on a week's notice. Go figure.)
Follow me at twitter.com/seantherebel and Like my page at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Tuesday, October 16, 2012
A reset of the Blog: Returning to judge wrestling
Most probably don't remember it, but more than a year ago, my MMA blog was an MMA and wrestling blog.
When I relaunched the blog after a lengthy hiatus, I cut wrestling out of the equation entirely, choosing to focus on legitimate types of fighting and going back to watching wrestling from the comfort of my own home and sharing my thoughts with family and friends only.
However, as time has gone on, I've missed being able to share my thoughts on wrestling from time to time, and I do want to give, albeit brief thoughts on the matches and segments as they go along. I had tried to do a brand competition where I ranked shows based on my enjoyment, but that died out after about a month.
But in order to come back, I was not sure where to put my thoughts. The MMA blog was a nice fit, but I worried about how the audience would see it now. My general blog was a nice choice since that's its point, but would making that blog SO diverse make the MMA blog feel like a useless appendage?
That's when it hit me: The Sports Blog.
Yes, this is the same blog where I used to share my thoughts on general sports topics. It's also the blog that hasn't posted anything in six months because I merged sports with the General Blog.
Now, this blog has a purpose. It will be a source of my thoughts on professional wrestling. I've left eight stories from the old Sports Blog era because of their readership and significance as the first installments of my "Why I..." columns.
Hope everyone enjoys and tunes into this new, third branch of The Sean Network Blogs.
Follow me at http://twitter.com/seantherebel and Like my blog at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
When I relaunched the blog after a lengthy hiatus, I cut wrestling out of the equation entirely, choosing to focus on legitimate types of fighting and going back to watching wrestling from the comfort of my own home and sharing my thoughts with family and friends only.
However, as time has gone on, I've missed being able to share my thoughts on wrestling from time to time, and I do want to give, albeit brief thoughts on the matches and segments as they go along. I had tried to do a brand competition where I ranked shows based on my enjoyment, but that died out after about a month.
But in order to come back, I was not sure where to put my thoughts. The MMA blog was a nice fit, but I worried about how the audience would see it now. My general blog was a nice choice since that's its point, but would making that blog SO diverse make the MMA blog feel like a useless appendage?
That's when it hit me: The Sports Blog.
Yes, this is the same blog where I used to share my thoughts on general sports topics. It's also the blog that hasn't posted anything in six months because I merged sports with the General Blog.
Now, this blog has a purpose. It will be a source of my thoughts on professional wrestling. I've left eight stories from the old Sports Blog era because of their readership and significance as the first installments of my "Why I..." columns.
Hope everyone enjoys and tunes into this new, third branch of The Sean Network Blogs.
Follow me at http://twitter.com/seantherebel and Like my blog at www.facebook.com/SeanNetworkBlogs.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










